From: Peter Ecclesine To: P8021 Subject: FW: 802.1P/D3 Date: Wed, 12 Jun 96 08:01:00 PDT SUBJECT: P802.1p/D3 - Traffic Class and Dynamic Multicast Filtering Services in Bridged LANs _XX___ I abstain for the following reasons: _XX___ Lack of Time __Peter Ecclesine_______ ---------------------------------------------------------------- Commments: reason for disapproval - Comment #1 - as many others, the Unicast Registration issue. (see other's comments on this) Comment #2 - I hope that the timer values can be made more binary, in particular T, Tl and Tla should be randomly chosen in the interval JoinTime < T < 1.125*JoinTime LeaveTime < Tl < 1.125*LeaveTime LeaveAllPeriod < Tla <= 1.125*LeaveAllPeriod SendLeavePDU Delay = 0.375*LeaveTime LeaveAllPDU Delay = 0.375*LeaveTime and in Table 9-6 JoinTime, a binary representation in integer microseconds.