Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

Re: [STDS-802-11-TGAX] D2.0 comment resolution status



Hello Robert and Zhou,

 

I have been reassigned the following BSR related CIDs in the section 27.5.3.6 (under MU Operation) by Abhi.

11323 11324 11325 11500 12198 12314 13193 13920 13921 14265 14324

 

To keep the comment resolution being consistent, Id like to resolve the CIDs in the section 9.2.4.6.4.5 BSR Control altogether (which are under “Queue size and BSR” below).

 

Could you please confirm the following CIDs to be reassigned to me?

11013, 11017, 11497, 11512, 11537, 11705, 11910, 11954, 11972, 11973, 11974, 11975, 12159, 12160, 12217, 12219, 12273, 12310, 12418, 12438, 12643, 12952, 12979, 12980, 13086, 13676, 13677, 13678, 13679, 13730, 13760, 14322, 14342, 14343,

 

Regards,

Kiseon

 

 

From: *** 802.11 TGax - HEW - High Efficiency WLAN *** [mailto:STDS-802-11-TGAX@xxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Stacey, Robert
Sent: Thursday, November 16, 2017 7:36 AM
To: STDS-802-11-TGAX@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Subject: Re: [STDS-802-11-TGAX] D2.0 comment resolution status

 

Here is another view: assignee and comment group:

 

Count of CID

Column Labels

Owning Ad-hoc

EDITOR

Grand Total

Bo Sun

64

64

PHY SAP

64

64

Edward Au

12

12

MIB

6

6

PiCS

6

6

Ron Porat

11

11

MAC General

2

2

Need Submission

1

1

PHY SAP

8

8

(blank)

960

960

6 GHz band

7

7

Editorials

882

882

Need Submission

2

2

Queue size and BSR

4

4

Sounding protocol

1

1

(blank)

64

64

Yongho Seok

50

50

Duration-based RTS/CTS

11

11

HT Control

19

19

MAC General

1

1

MU operation

8

8

PHY PPDU formats

7

7

PHY SAP

2

2

Sounding protocol

2

2

Youhan Kim

91

91

DFS operation

14

14

Packet extension

19

19

PHY OFDMA overview

52

52

TXTIME

6

6

Sigurd Schelstraete

5

5

HE-SIG-B

5

5

Hongyuan Zhang

183

183

A-MPDU

1

1

HE-SIG-A

3

3

HE-SIG-B

1

1

Mathematical description

108

108

PHY Data field

50

50

PHY Preamble

20

20

Matt Fischer

194

194

Spatial Reuse

194

194

Ross

15

15

Ack procedure

1

1

Editorials

2

2

HE-SIG-A

5

5

HE-SIG-B

1

1

Mathematical description

3

3

PHY Data field

1

1

PHY Intro

1

1

PHY Preamble

1

1

Xiaogang Chen

63

63

PHY SAP

2

2

PHY tx blocks and encoding

46

46

PHY tx/rx procedure

15

15

Bin Tian

8

8

MCS overview and tables

8

8

Ming Gan

100

100

Fragmentation

100

100

Yujin Noh

21

21

HE-SIG-B

20

20

Mathematical description

1

1

Tomoko Adachi

48

48

Ack procedure

48

48

Lochan Verma

152

152

Editorials

2

2

HE-SIG-A

22

22

HE-SIG-B

21

21

PHY Intro

100

100

Sounding protocol

7

7

Laurent Cariou

48

48

EDCA

12

12

NDP feedback

36

36

Guoqing Li

83

83

General and MAC services

32

32

Operating mode

30

30

Power management

21

21

Alfred Asterjadhi

341

341

EDCA

5

5

Format and rate selection

34

34

Fragmentation

1

1

HE BSS operation

37

37

MAC General

1

1

Multi-BSS

2

2

NAV

1

1

Need Submission

2

2

PHY tx/rx spec

12

12

Sounding protocol

79

79

TWT

164

164

(blank)

3

3

George Cherian

186

186

Ack procedure

186

186

Frank Hsu

17

17

Link adaptation

17

17

ChaoChun Wang

19

19

HE BSS operation

19

19

Po-Kai Huang

89

89

MU-RTS/CTS

27

27

NAV

61

61

Need Submission

1

1

Abhishek Patil

197

197

Editorials

1

1

HE BSS operation

11

11

MAC General

4

4

MU operation

158

158

Multi-BSS

9

9

Spatial Reuse

1

1

UORA

13

13

Jarkko Kneckt

2

2

Reverse direction

2

2

Liwen Chu

126

126

A-MPDU

110

110

Editorials

6

6

Sounding protocol

10

10

Chitto Ghosh

18

18

UORA

18

18

Osama Aboul-Magd

1

1

(blank)

1

1

Zhou Lan

65

65

BQR operation

24

24

EDCA

1

1

MU operation

9

9

Need Submission

1

1

PHY OFDMA overview

3

3

Queue size and BSR

25

25

Sounding protocol

2

2

Jianhan Liu

50

50

PHY tx/rx spec

50

50

Tianyu Wu

23

23

HE-SIG-B

1

1

PHY Intro

3

3

PHY PPDU formats

18

18

PHY Preamble

1

1

Jeongki Kim

8

8

UORA

8

8

Yunbo Li

1

1

Reverse direction

1

1

Kome Oteri

18

18

Editorials

6

6

PHY SU/MU-MIMO Beamforming

3

3

Sounding protocol

9

9

Jae Seung

19

19

MLME SAP

16

16

MU operation

3

3

Stephane Baron

14

14

UORA

14

14

Kiseon

2

2

MU-RTS/CTS

1

1

(blank)

1

1

Jing Ma

4

4

MU operation

4

4

Grand Total

3308

3308

 

-Robert

 

From: *** 802.11 TGax - HEW - High Efficiency WLAN *** [mailto:STDS-802-11-TGAX@xxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Stacey, Robert
Sent: Wednesday, November 15, 2017 2:30 PM
To: STDS-802-11-TGAX@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Subject: [STDS-802-11-TGAX] D2.0 comment resolution status

 

Hello All,

 

I have uploaded a revision of the comment spreadsheet. This revision the resolutions to 37 comments adopted at the November session. It reflects the current assignments.

 

Here is a summary by comment group and resolution state:

 

Count of CID

Column Labels

Owning Ad-hoc

Unassigned

Assigned

Resolution Drafted

Approved

Grand Total

EDITOR

960

2348

5

37

3350

6 GHz band

7

 

 

 

7

Ack procedure

 

235

 

 

235

A-MPDU

 

111

 

 

111

BQR operation

 

24

 

 

24

DFS operation

 

14

 

 

14

Duration-based RTS/CTS

 

11

 

 

11

EDCA

 

18

 

 

18

Editorials

882

17

 

3

902

Format and rate selection

 

34

 

 

34

Fragmentation

 

101

 

 

101

General and MAC services

 

32

 

 

32

HE BSS operation

 

67

 

 

67

HE-SIG-A

 

30

 

 

30

HE-SIG-B

 

49

 

 

49

HT Control

 

19

 

 

19

Link adaptation

 

17

 

 

17

MAC General

 

8

5

 

13

Mathematical description

 

112

 

 

112

MCS overview and tables

 

8

 

 

8

MIB

 

6

 

4

10

MLME SAP

 

16

 

 

16

MU operation

 

182

 

1

183

Multi-BSS

 

11

 

 

11

MU-RTS/CTS

 

28

 

 

28

NAV

 

62

 

 

62

NDP feedback

 

36

 

 

36

Need Submission

2

5

 

 

7

Operating mode

 

30

 

 

30

Packet extension

 

19

 

 

19

PHY Data field

 

51

 

 

51

PHY Intro

 

104

 

 

104

PHY OFDMA overview

 

55

 

19

74

PHY PPDU formats

 

25

 

 

25

PHY Preamble

 

22

 

 

22

PHY SAP

 

76

 

6

82

PHY SU/MU-MIMO Beamforming

 

3

 

 

3

PHY tx blocks and encoding

 

46

 

 

46

PHY tx/rx procedure

 

15

 

 

15

PHY tx/rx spec

 

62

 

1

63

PiCS

 

6

 

3

9

Power management

 

21

 

 

21

Queue size and BSR

4

25

 

 

29

Reverse direction

 

3

 

 

3

Sounding protocol

1

109

 

 

110

Spatial Reuse

 

195

 

 

195

TWT

 

164

 

 

164

TXTIME

 

6

 

 

6

UORA

 

53

 

 

53

(blank)

64

5

 

 

69

Grand Total

960

2348

5

37

3350

 

 

Here is a summary by assignee:

 

Count of CID

Column Labels

Owning Ad-hoc

EDITOR

Grand Total

Bo Sun

64

64

G

1

1

T

63

63

Edward Au

12

12

T

12

12

Ron Porat

11

11

T

11

11

(blank)

960

960

E

872

872

G

19

19

T

69

69

Yongho Seok

50

50

G

3

3

T

47

47

Youhan Kim

91

91

G

6

6

T

85

85

Sigurd Schelstraete

5

5

T

5

5

Hongyuan Zhang

183

183

T

183

183

Matt Fischer

194

194

G

6

6

T

188

188

Ross

15

15

E

2

2

T

13

13

Xiaogang Chen

63

63

G

2

2

T

61

61

Bin Tian

8

8

T

8

8

Ming Gan

100

100

G

5

5

T

95

95

Yujin Noh

21

21

G

4

4

T

17

17

Tomoko Adachi

48

48

G

6

6

T

42

42

Lochan Verma

152

152

E

2

2

G

5

5

T

145

145

Laurent Cariou

48

48

G

1

1

T

47

47

Guoqing Li

83

83

G

6

6

T

77

77

Alfred Asterjadhi

341

341

G

6

6

T

335

335

George Cherian

186

186

G

4

4

T

182

182

Frank Hsu

17

17

G

1

1

T

16

16

ChaoChun Wang

19

19

T

19

19

Po-Kai Huang

89

89

G

4

4

T

85

85

Abhishek Patil

197

197

E

1

1

G

9

9

T

187

187

Jarkko Kneckt

2

2

T

2

2

Liwen Chu

126

126

E

6

6

G

4

4

T

116

116

Chitto Ghosh

18

18

T

18

18

Osama Aboul-Magd

1

1

G

1

1

Zhou Lan

65

65

G

2

2

T

63

63

Jianhan Liu

50

50

G

1

1

T

49

49

Tianyu Wu

23

23

G

3

3

T

20

20

Jeongki Kim

8

8

T

8

8

Yunbo Li

1

1

T

1

1

Kome Oteri

18

18

E

6

6

T

12

12

Jae Seung

19

19

G

2

2

T

17

17

Stephane Baron

14

14

T

14

14

Kiseon

2

2

T

2

2

Jing Ma

4

4

T

4

4

Grand Total

3308

3308

 

-Robert

 

_______________________________________________________________________________

If you wish to be removed from this reflector, do not send your request to this reflector - it will have no effect.

Instead, go to http://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-TGAX and then press the LEAVE button.

Further information can be found at: http://www.ieee802.org/11/Email_Subscribe.html _______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

If you wish to be removed from this reflector, do not send your request to this reflector - it will have no effect.

Instead, go to http://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-TGAX and then press the LEAVE button.

Further information can be found at: http://www.ieee802.org/11/Email_Subscribe.html _______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

If you wish to be removed from this reflector, do not send your request to this reflector - it will have no effect.

Instead, go to http://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-TGAX and then press the LEAVE button.

Further information can be found at: http://www.ieee802.org/11/Email_Subscribe.html _______________________________________________________________________________