IEEE 802.16 Letter Ballot #24: Current Ballot Status Report

Letter Ballot #24 progress, in inverse chronological order:

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot Recirc #24a: Announcement {CLOSED}

Call for Additional Comments: Announcement {CLOSED}

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #24: Announcement {CLOSED}

Summary Results

Report Date Approve Dis Sum Approval
Ratio
Approval Ratio
Condition Met
(>75%)
Abstain Ballots Members Return
Ratio
Return Ratio
Condition Met
(>=50%)
Return
Shortfall
Approval+
2007/03/05 97 42 139 .7 No 32 171 227 .75 Yes 0 No+
+At the IEEE 802.16 Session #49 Closing Plenary Meeting of 10 May 2007, the WG made the decision to terminate WG Letter Ballot #24. Following further Task Group development of the draft, a new WG Letter Ballot is expected to reconsider the Task Group output.

Ballot Details

[ Updated 07/03/05, 02:17 PM (MT) ]
Note: This report is infrequently updated while the ballot is open. However, you may check a real-time report of ballot submittals.

Name\Family Name\Given Letter Ballot #24
Abrishami Ray Approve, No Comments
Agis Edward Approve, No Comments
Ali Murtaza Approve, No Comments
Andelman Dov Approve, No Comments
Asa Masahito Disapprove (a)
Athalye Sanjeev Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Austin Mark -
Barber Phillip Disapprove
Baum Kevin Disapprove (a)
Bhalla Rajesh -
Bogenfeld Eckard Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Brandt Achim Disapprove
Cai Sean Approve, No Comments (a)
Carlo James Disapprove
Castelow David -
Cavalli Giulio -
Cha Jaesun Approve, No Comments (a)
Chang Dean -
Chang Jae Hwan Approve, No Comments
Chang Sungcheol Approve, No Comments
Chayat Naftali -
Chayer Rémi Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Chen David Approve, No Comments (a)
Chen Yuehua (Lucy) -
Chindapol Aik Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Cho Jaehee Approve, No Comments
Cho Jaeweon Approve, No Comments
Cho Kihyoung Approve, No Comments (a)
Cho Seokheon Approve, No Comments (a)
Choi Hyoung-Jin -
Choi Joonyoung Approve, No Comments
Choi Yang-Seok Approve, No Comments
Choi Yun -
Chou Joey Approve, No Comments
Chun Jin Young Approve, No Comments (a)
Chung Yun Won -
Cook Thomas Approve, No Comments
Costa José Approve, No Comments
Cudak Mark Disapprove
Cummings George Disapprove
Dang Shujun Disapprove
Draper Frank -
Dudzinski Krzysztof Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Eastwood Lester Approve, No Comments (a)
Edler Tomas Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Eklund Carl Disapprove
Elmdahl Per Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Fahldieck Torsten Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (a)
Feder Peretz -
Feng Dazi -
Fong Mo-Han Approve, No Comments
Freedman Avraham Disapprove
Fu I-Kang Approve, No Comments
Fu Yan Disapprove
Giesberts Pieter-Paul Approve, No Comments
Goldhamer Mariana Disapprove
Golshan Reza -
Grandblaise David Disapprove (a)
Guo Qiang -
Han Jung Ho Approve, No Comments
Hanaoka Seishi -
Harrang Jeff Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (a)
Hart Mike Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (a)
Henderson Gregory Scott -
Hoghooghi Michael Approve, No Comments
Holmes David Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Hsiao Chang-Lung Approve, No Comments
Huang Haiming Approve, No Comments
Humbert John -
Hur Yerang Disapprove
Hwang InSeok Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Ibbetson Luke -
Ihm Bin-Chul Approve, No Comments (a)
Jeong Moo Ryong Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Johnson Brian Approve, No Comments
Johnsson Kerstin Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Johnston David Disapprove
Joo Panyuh Approve, No Comments
Kado Youiti -
Kanai Takeo -
Kang Hyunjeong Approve, No Comments
Kelman Ofer Approve, No Comments
Kiernan Brian Approve, No Comments (a)
Kim Beomjoon Approve, No Comments
Kim Bong Ho Disapprove
Kim Byoung-Jo Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Kim Dae-Joong -
Kim Ronny (Yong-Ho) Approve, No Comments (a)
Kim Sang Youb Approve, No Comments
Kim Youngho -
Kim YoungKyun Approve, No Comments
Kitroser Itzik Disapprove
Koo Changhoi Approve, No Comments
Koorapaty Havish Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Kuze Toshiyuki Approve, No Comments (a)
Kwon Dong Seung -
Labs Jonathan Disapprove
Laihonen Kari -
Lee Geunho -
Lee Hyunjeong Approve, No Comments
Lee Mihyun -
Lee Sang-Ho -
Lee Sungjin -
Lee Youn-Tai Approve, No Comments
Lewis Barry -
Li Jia-Ru -
Li Jiang Disapprove (a)
Li Jun Approve, No Comments
Li Thomas Disapprove
Licitra Gaspare Disapprove
Lim Aeri Approve, No Comments
Lim Geunhwi Approve, No Comments
Lim Hyoung Kyu Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Lim Sun Ju Approve, No Comments
Lin Tzu-Ming Approve, No Comments (a)
Lin Zhibin Disapprove
Lycklama Heinz -
Lynch Michael Approve, No Comments
Ma Steve -
Maez David Approve, No Comments (a)
Maidment David Approve, No Comments
Makhijani Mahesh Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Mandin Jeffrey Approve, No Comments
Mao Ronald Disapprove (a)
Marks Roger Disapprove
Matatyaou Asaf -
Migaldi Scott Disapprove (a)
Mollenauer James Approve, No Comments (a)
Mont-Reynaud Ollivier Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Muenzner Roland -
Mulder Willem Approve, No Comments (a)
Nakamura Kenichi Approve, No Comments
Nakamura Michiharu Approve, No Comments
Natarajan K.S. Approve, No Comments
Nohara Mitsuo -
Odlyzko Paul Approve, No Comments (a)
Oh Min Seok Approve, No Comments (a)
Oprea Radu -
Paranchych David Approve, No Comments
Park DS Approve, No Comments
Peterson Roger Disapprove
Piggin Paul Disapprove
Poston Jeff Approve, No Comments
Poulin Darcy Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Probasco Scott -
Puthenkulam Jose Approve, Comments
qian nanjian (jeff) Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (a)
Qu Hongyun Approve, No Comments (a)
Raghavan Arvind Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Ramachandran Shyamal Approve, No Comments (a)
Rayal Frank Approve, No Comments
Reid Anthony -
Ren Fang-Ching Approve, No Comments
Retnasothie Francis Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Riegel Maximilian Disapprove
Roh Wonil Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Ruck Herbert -
Rush Charles -
Ryu Kiseon Approve, No Comments (a)
Saifullah Yousuf Approve, No Comments (a)
Saito Kenji Approve, No Comments
Schlanger Gary Approve, No Comments
Schmidt Jörg -
Schumacher Joseph Approve, No Comments (a)
Sharon Ariel Approve, No Comments (a)
Shasha Eliyahu -
Sheen Wern-Ho -
Sherman Matthew Disapprove
Shyy D. J. Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Simkins James -
Sivanesan Kathiravetpillai -
Sjoberg Sten Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Somerville Clare -
Son Jung Je Approve, No Comments
Son Yeong Moon -
Stafford Robert Approve, No Comments (a)
Stanwood Kenneth Disapprove
Suh Kyungjoo Approve, No Comments
Sun Yong -
Sydir Jaroslaw Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Sydor John Disapprove (a)
Tang Xiangguo -
Taori Rakesh -
Taylor Shawn Approve, No Comments (a)
Teo Koon Hoo Approve, No Comments (a)
Tong Wen Approve, No Comments
Tsai Shiau-He Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Ullmann Rainer Approve, No Comments
Urban David -
Vadgama Sunil Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Valbonesi Lucia Approve, No Comments (a)
Van Leeuwen Richard Approve, No Comments (a)
Verbin Eyal Approve, No Comments
Viorel Dorin Approve, No Comments
Vook Frederick Disapprove
Wallenius Eero Approve, No Comments
Wang Arthur Approve, No Comments
Wang Guo Qiang Approve, No Comments
Wang Irving -
Wang Jing Approve, No Comments
Wang Lei Disapprove
Wang Michael Approve, No Comments
Wang Shu-Shaw Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (a)
Wang Stanley Approve, No Comments
Waung William -
Wennstrom Mattias Disapprove (a)
Wieczorek Alfred Disapprove
Wu Geng Approve, No Comments
Wu Xuyong Disapprove
Wu Yingzhe Disapprove
Xiang David Disapprove
Xu Ling Approve, No Comments
Xu Shanshan Approve, No Comments
Yagi Akiyoshi Approve, No Comments (a)
Yang Yunsong Disapprove
Yaniv Ran Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Yanover Vladimir Approve, No Comments
Yin Hujun Approve, No Comments (a)
Youn Aeran Approve, No Comments (a)
Yun Jungnam -
Yun Mi-Young -
Yuza Masaaki Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Zein Nader Disapprove
Zhu Chenxi Approve, No Comments
Zhu Peiying Approve, No Comments
Zhu Yongjin Disapprove
Zou Lan Disapprove (a)
(a) Recirc #24a, or post-deadline in #24.