IEEE 802.16 Letter Ballot #25: Ballot Report

Letter Ballot #25 progress, in inverse chronological order:

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot Recirculation #25d: Announcement {CLOSED}

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot Recirculation #25c: Announcement {CLOSED}

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot Recirculation #25b: Announcement {CLOSED}

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot Recirculation #25a: Announcement {CLOSED}

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #25: Announcement {CLOSED}

Summary Results

Report Date Approve Dis Sum Approval
Ratio
Approval Ratio
Condition Met
(>75%)
Abstain Ballots Members Return
Ratio
Return Ratio
Condition Met
(>=50%)
Return
Shortfall
Approval+
2007/10/30 139 8 147 .95 Yes 16 163 212 .77 Yes 0 Yes
+Pending comment resolution and recirculation. Note: This ballot has been terminated. The P802.16i PAR was withdrawn by the IEEE-SA Standards Board on 26 March 2008, at the request of the 802.16 Working Group. The content of the P802.16i draft was moved into P802.16Rev2 draft.

Ballot Details

[ Updated 07/10/30, 11:56 AM ]
Note: This report is infrequently updated while the ballot is open. However, you may check a real-time report of ballot submittals.

Name\Family Name\Given Letter Ballot #25
Abrishami Ray -
Ahmadi Sassan Approve, No Comments (c)
Ahn Junbae -
Andelman Dov Approve, No Comments
Arefi Reza Approve, No Comments
Asa Masahito -
Athalye Sanjeev -
Barber Phillip Approve, No Comments
Basgeet Dharma Approve, No Comments
Baum Kevin -
Boariu Adrian Approve, No Comments (c)
Bogenfeld Eckard Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Brandt Achim Approve, No Comments
Branlund Dale Approve, No Comments
Carlo James Approve, No Comments (a)
Castelow David -
Cha Jaesun Approve, No Comments (d)
Chang Jae Hwan Approve, No Comments (a)
Chang Sungcheol Approve, No Comments
Chayer Rémi Approve, No Comments
Chen David Approve, No Comments
Chen Wei-Peng Approve, No Comments (d)
Chindapol Aik Approve, No Comments
Cho Jaehee Approve, No Comments (d)
Cho Jaeweon Approve, No Comments (a)
Cho Seokheon -
Choi Joonyoung Approve, No Comments (a)
Choi Yang-Seok Approve, No Comments
Chou Joey Disapprove
Colban Erik Disapprove
Comstock David -
Costa José Approve, No Comments
Cudak Mark Approve, No Comments
Cummings George -
Dayal Pranav Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
De Segovia Carlos Approve, No Comments (d)
Draper Frank -
Eastwood Lester Approve, No Comments
Eklund Carl Approve, No Comments
Elmdahl Per Approve, No Comments
Feder Peretz -
Fong Mo-Han Approve, No Comments
Freedman Avraham Approve, No Comments
Fu I-Kang Approve, No Comments (d)
Gal Dan -
Giesberts Pieter-Paul Approve, No Comments
Goldhamer Mariana Approve, No Comments
Golshan Reza -
Grandblaise David Approve, No Comments (c)
Han Jung Ho Approve, No Comments (a)
Harrang Jeff Approve, No Comments (c)
Hart Mike Approve, No Comments
Holmes David -
Hsiao Chang-Lung Approve, No Comments (b)
Hsieh Ching-Tarng Approve, No Comments (b)
Hu Teck -
Humbert John Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (c)
Hur Yerang -
Hwang InSeok Approve, No Comments (a)
Ikeda Tetsu Approve, No Comments
Jeon Hyung Joon -
Jeong Moo Ryong Approve, No Comments
Johnson Brian Approve, No Comments
Johnsson Kerstin -
Johnston David Approve, No Comments
Joo Panyuh Approve, No Comments (d)
Kang Hyunjeong Approve, No Comments (a)
Kaplan Ted Approve, No Comments
Kelman Ofer Approve, No Comments
Kiernan Brian Approve, No Comments
Kim Beomjoon -
Kim Bong Ho -
Kim Byoung-Jo -
Kim Eunah -
Kim Hyung Kee Approve, No Comments
Kim Ronny (Yong-Ho) Approve, No Comments
Kim Sang Youb Approve, No Comments
Kim Sungkyung Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (d)
Kim Young Kyun -
Kim Young-Il -
Kim Youngho Approve, No Comments (a)
Kitroser Itzik Approve, No Comments (c)
Kong Peng-Yong Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Koo Changhoi Approve, No Comments (c)
Koorapaty Havish Approve, No Comments
Kuze Toshiyuki Approve, No Comments (d)
Labs Jonathan Approve, No Comments
Laihonen Kari -
Lamoureux Jules Pierre -
Lee Geon Yong -
Lee Hyun Approve, No Comments (c)
Lee Hyunjeong Approve, No Comments (a)
Lee Kyu Ha Approve, No Comments (b)
Lee Mihyun Approve, No Comments (c)
Lee Sungjin -
Lee Youn-Tai Approve, No Comments
Lee Yung-Ting Approve, No Comments
Leiba Yigal Approve, No Comments
Levanda Matty Approve, No Comments (a)
Li Jiang Approve, No Comments (b)
Li Jun Approve, No Comments
Li Thomas -
Licitra Gaspare Approve, No Comments
Lim Aeri Approve, No Comments (a)
Lim Geunhwi -
Lim Hyoung Kyu Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (a)
Lin Jiezhen Approve, No Comments
Lin Tzu-Ming Approve, No Comments (d)
Lin Zhibin Disapprove
Livschitz Michael Approve, No Comments (b)
Lo Titus Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (b)
Loa Kanchei Approve, No Comments
Lynch Michael Approve, No Comments
Maez David Approve, No Comments (d)
Maheshwari Shashikant Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (c)
Maidment David -
Mao Ronald Disapprove
Marks Roger Disapprove
Matatyaou Asaf -
Meddour Djamal-Eddine Approve, No Comments
Migaldi Scott Approve, No Comments (c)
Mollenauer James Approve, No Comments
Mont-Reynaud Ollivier -
Mulder Willem Approve, No Comments
Nagai Yukimasa Approve, No Comments (c)
Nakamura Kenichi Approve, No Comments
Nakamura Michiharu Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (b)
Natarajan K.S. -
Nohara Mitsuo Approve, No Comments (c)
Norin John Approve, No Comments
Odlyzko Paul -
Oh Changyoon Approve, No Comments (a)
Paranchych David Approve, No Comments
Park DS -
Peterson Roger -
Piggin Paul Approve, No Comments
Popoli Robert Approve, No Comments
Poulin Darcy Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Probasco Scott Approve, No Comments (c)
Puthenkulam Jose Approve, No Comments
Qian Nanjian (Jeff) Approve, No Comments (b)
Raghavan Arvind Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Ramachandran Shyamal Approve, No Comments
Rayal Frank Approve, No Comments (b)
Ren Fang-Ching Approve, No Comments (b)
Riegel Maximilian Approve, No Comments (c)
Roh Wonil Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (a)
Rubin Philip Approve, No Comments
Ruck Herbert Approve, No Comments
Ryu Kiseon Approve, No Comments
Saifullah Yousuf Approve, No Comments (d)
Saito Kenji Approve, No Comments (c)
Sandhu Sumeet -
Schlanger Gary Approve, No Comments
Schumacher Joseph -
Seagren Chris Approve, No Comments
Senarath Gamini Approve, No Comments
Sharon Ariel Approve, No Comments (b)
Shasha Eliyahu Approve, No Comments
Sherman Matthew Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Shibayama Hitoshi -
Shyy D. J. Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Sivanesan Kathiravetpillai -
Sjoberg Sten Approve, No Comments
Son Jung Je Approve, No Comments
Son Yeong Moon Approve, No Comments (b)
Stafford Robert Approve, No Comments
Stanwood Kenneth Approve, No Comments
Steer David Approve, No Comments
Suh Kyungjoo -
Sydir Jaroslaw Approve, No Comments
Sydor John Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (c)
Takatani Yukihiro Approve, No Comments (b)
Taori Rakesh -
Taylor Shawn Approve, No Comments (d)
Thome Timothy Approve, No Comments
Tong Wen Approve, No Comments
Tonnerre Arnaud Approve, No Comments
Tsai Shiau-He Approve, No Comments
Ullmann Rainer -
Vadgama Sunil -
Valbonesi Lucia Approve, No Comments
Van Leeuwen Richard Approve, No Comments (a)
Verbin Eyal Approve, No Comments
Viorel Dorin Approve, No Comments (d)
Vook Frederick Approve, No Comments
Wallenius Eero Approve, No Comments
Wang Guo qiang Approve, No Comments
Wang Lei Approve, No Comments
Wang Michael Approve, No Comments
Wang Stanley Approve, No Comments
Wang Yanhong Disapprove
Webb Michael Approve, Comments
Wieczorek Alfred Approve, No Comments (d)
Wu Geng -
Wu Xuyong -
Wu Yingzhe Disapprove
Xiang David Approve, No Comments (a)
Xu Kaixin Approve, No Comments
Yagi Akiyoshi Approve, No Comments (d)
Yang Jen-Shun Approve, No Comments (a)
Yang Yunsong Disapprove
Yanover Vladimir Approve, No Comments
Yin Hua-Chiang Approve, No Comments
Yin Hujun Approve, No Comments
Yun Jungnam Approve, No Comments (a)
Yuza Masaaki Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Zein Nader -
Zhang Jinyun Approve, No Comments (d)
Zhu Chenxi Approve, No Comments
Zhu Peiying Approve, No Comments
Zhu Yongjin -

(a) Recirc #25a
(b) Recirc #25b
(c) Recirc #25c
*Following ballot close and/or comment resolution.