| Attendees: Held as part of 802.17 WG plenary session, so all attendees of the WG were attendees of the IEEE P802.17 Maintenance Task Group. |
| Maintenance request 0006 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: In rows 4 and 5 of Table 7.22 in the condition cell, add the condition: frame.ft != FT_FAIRNESS |
| Maintenance request 0007 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: In Table 10.13 Row 5 add the action: receivedTtl = frame.ttl. Remove the comment from the condition on the same row. |
| Maintenance request 0008 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Replace the label in this box with: crcB = headCrc16(d) |
| Maintenance request 0010 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Change the reference to Max() in 10.2.4 to refer to the definition of Max() in 7.2.3. [See resoution of MR 23.] |
| Maintenance request 0011 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Change the entire text of 13.3.1.2 to "The RPR interface operational state (RFC 2863) is determined as follows: * Down if either of the following conditions is true: * RPR interface administrative state (RFC 2863) is down. * Both spans are edges. * Otherwise up.". |
| Maintenance request 0012 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: As specified in maint_0012_rate_corrections.txt. |
| Maintenance request 0013 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Accept proposed rememdy. Y:3, N:0, A:5 |
| Maintenance request 0014 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: No New status: J Resolution: This is considered to be an enhancement, not an error. [This addressed by P802.17b.] |
| Maintenance request 0016 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: This is superceded by MR 13. |
| Maintenance request 0018 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: No New status: W |
| Maintenance request 0019 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Move "lastCreditC = creditC;" from first line to last line of the action for Row 9. |
| Maintenance request 0020 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Show protocolType starting 16 bits into a 32-bit alignment of the frame. Remove A1 byte, and reletter the remaining data bytes starting from A. Recalculate the FCS. |
| Maintenance request 0021 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Change "TransmitCount" to "TransmitRoute". |
| Maintenance request 0022 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: In SP3, change "MA_CONTROL.request with an opcode value of OAM_ECHO_REQ" to "MA_CONTROL.request with an opcode value of OAM_FLUSH_REQ", and change "Echo flush formats" to "Flush formats". In SP4, change "MA_CONTROL.indication with an opcode value of OAM_ECHO_IND" to "MA_CONTROL.indication with an opcode value of OAM_FLUSH_IND", and change "Echo flush formats" to "Flush formats". |
| Maintenance request 0023 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: In Table 7.11 Row 1, Table 7.12 Row 1, Table 7.13 Row 1, and Table 7.13 Row 2, change "Min" to "Max". Move the definition of Max forward to Clause 7. Change other references to Max() to refer to the Clause 7 definition. |
| Maintenance request 0024 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: For both Table 7.11 and 7.12, move Row 1 to a new state AVAIL. Existing Rows 3 and 4 next state becomes AVAIL. In AVAIL, add a new row following the previous Row 1 with a condition of "--", action of "--", and next state of START. Add or correct row descriptions to match these changes. |
| Maintenance request 0025 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: New status: T Discussion: Replace "NORM" to "ageCoef * rateCoef". Remove references to NORM. Add reference to ageCoef and rateCoef. |
| Maintenance request 0026 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Change last sentence to "See 13.3.1 for specifics on interface state.". |
| Maintenance request 0027 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: No New status: J Resolution: The error is with ringlet selection, not with OAM service requests. |
| Maintenance request 0028 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Move these two attributes from the rprIfEntry to the rprSpanProtectionEntry, obsoleting these two rprIfEntry attributes. |
| Maintenance request 0029 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Remove Row 16. Remove the condition from Row 15. |
| Maintenance request 0031 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Switch the row descriptions for Row 3 and Row 4. |
| Maintenance request 0032 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Modify the statemachine table and 11.6.2.2 to correctly apply these on a per-ringlet basis. |
| Maintenance request 0033 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Change the declaration and any references from "adminRequestProtection" to "adminReqProtection". |
| Maintenance request 0034 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: New status: T |
| Maintenance request 0035 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Change the row description to "Otherwise, no topology database update is needed." |
| Maintenance request 0036 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: No New status: J Resolution: There are direct relationships between the named state machines. |
| Maintenance request 0037 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: New status: T |
| Maintenance request 0038 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Add a PICS entry and correct the rprFairnessRingletWeight MIB description to reflect the option of limiting values to powers of 2. |
| Maintenance request 0039 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Add a MIB attribute for stabilityTimeout in rprIfEntry, called rprIfTopoStabilityTimer. |
| Maintenance request 0040 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Change the description of rprIfCurrentStatus to indicate that it provides the current defect status. Add the defects in 11.2.9 that are not included in this bit field. |
| Maintenance request 0041 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Change the wrapActive{West,East} bits to edge{West,East}. Add references to spanEdge variable in reference for rprTopoImageStatus. |
| Maintenance request 0042 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Add "Only one status bit is active at once." to the description of each of these. |
| Maintenance request 0043 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Change "receivedBadFcs" to "badFcsUser". Change "receivedMultichokeFairness" to "multichokeUser". Correct their descriptions to indicate that these advertise what a station wishes to receive. |
| Maintenance request 0044 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Remove the extraneous '}' after the first for statement of SecondaryMacCount(), the extraneous '}' before the return statement of SecondaryMacCount(), and the extraneous '{' at the end of the line of the third for statement of SecondaryMacValidation(). |
| Maintenance request 0050 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B In Table 7.13, Row 1, replace "Min(0,creditS-1)" with "Max(0,creditS-1)", and in Row 2, replace "Min(0,creditS+1)" with "Max(0,creditS+1)". |
| Maintenance request 0051 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Change "the management system" to "a station". |
| Maintenance request 0052 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: In addition to rprSpanStatsInOamEchoFrames, add rprSpanStatsInOamEchoReqFrames and rprSpanStatsInOamEchoRspFrames. In addition to rprSpanStatsOutOamEchoFrames, add rprSpanStatsOutOamEchoReqFrames and rprSpanStatsOutOamEchoRspFrames. |
| Maintenance request 0053 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: No New status: J Resolution: The MIB may not be as clear as it could be, but it is correct. |
| Maintenance request 0054 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: New status: T |
| Maintenance request 0055 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: New status: T |
| Maintenance request 0056 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0057 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0058 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0059 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0060 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0061 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0062 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0063 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0064 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0065 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0066 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0067 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0068 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0069 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0070 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0071 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0072 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0073 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0074 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0075 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0076 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |