Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

Re: [802.3_100GCU] Optics - No AN for FEC



Hi Jeff,

Some people have received your comments as suggesting that the entire Optics SG endorsed the position of that presentation or the key takeaways.

I reviewed your comment and do not see you making that case, however, the title of the email might be suggestive of that. I am pretty sure you did not intend to suggest that, but a title like "System View on Optics - No AN for FEC" might have avoided even the most subtle implication.

But just for clarity's sake, I will assert it very concisely. "The position stated in that presentation does not reflect the position of the entire SG. The Next Generation Optics SG has not taken a position yet."

I am 100% sure you will agree with me on that. Hopefully in our next meeting, we can get some straw polling or motions to adopt language on this question.

Regards,

Dan

From: Jeffery Maki <jmaki@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Reply-To: Jeffery Maki <jmaki@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Date: Fri, 27 Jan 2012 14:09:18 -0800
To: <STDS-802-3-100GCU@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Subject: Re: [802.3_100GCU] Optics - No AN for FEC

For those of you who were not in the 802.3bj task force meeting this morning,

 

I wanted to make clear that I sent the message below in response to questions at the microphone this morning regarding whether auto-negotiation of FEC is needed or wanted for optics.

 

Jeff

 

From: Jeffery Maki
Sent: Friday, January 27, 2012 10:24 AM
To: STDS-802-3-100GCU@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Subject: Optics - No AN for FEC

 

All,

 

In the NG 100G Optical Ethernet Study Group this week, the presentation http://www.ieee802.org/3/100GNGOPTX/public/jan12/traverso_01_0112_NG100GOPTX.pdf was made by Gary Nicholl with the key statement:

 

If new PMD(s) employ FEC, preference is that it is mandatory

Low Latency FEC is preferred

Proliferation of FEC types is burdensome

 

Auto-negotiation is not sought. The presence or lack of presence of FEC is considered to be a separate PMD.  See slide 11 on how to manage FEC over various PMDs.

 

Title slide with author list:

More thoughts on FEC

Jan-2012

Matt Traverso, Cisco

Gary Nicholl, Cisco

Jeffery Maki, Juniper

 

 

Slide with broad list of system-centric supporters:

Supporters

Joel Goergen, Cisco

Ted Sprague, Infinera

Scott Kipp, Brocade

Dan Dove, Applied Micro

John D’Ambrosia, Dell

Kapil Shrikhande, Dell

 

 

Jeffery Maki

Juniper Networks, Inc.