IEEE P802.3at DTE Power Enhancements Task Force

Comments received during Working Group ballot

D3.1

September 2008 Interim: Seoul, Korea

        Unsatisfied comments from D3.0, sorted by clause

Attachments

D3.0

July 2008 Plenary: Denver, CO

        Closed comments needing signoff, sorted by ID
        All comments, sorted by clause
        All comments, sorted by ID
        Comment database v4.4 (zipped MS Access)

June 2008 Interim: Durham, NH

        Open comments, sorted by clause
        All comments, sorted by clause
        All comments, sorted by ID
        Comment database v4.4 (zipped MS Access)
        All comments, sorted by clause
        All comments, sorted by ID

May 2008 Interim: Munich, Germany

        All comments, sorted by clause
        All comments, sorted by ID
        Closed comments, sorted by clause
        Closed comments, sorted by ID
        EZ Bucket comments
        Closed comments, Day 1
        Comment database v4.4b (zipped MS Access)
        All new comments, edited, sorted by clause
        All new comments, edited, sorted by ID
        All new comments, unedited, sorted by clause
        All new comments, unedited, sorted by ID
        Comment database v4.4 (zipped MS Access)

Attachments

        Darshan: 33.4.8.2 Updates for Draft D3.0 Rev 005.pdf
        Darshan: Draft D.3 - 33C_4.vsd
        Darshan: Figure 33-24-1. Midspan Transfer Function for draft D3.0 - Rev 003.vsd
        Darshan: Opt_Vport_lim Figure 33-6 rev 003.pdf
        Darshan: PD Test mode.vsd
        Darshan: Revised 33C.4.pdf
        Darshan: Updated figure 33-11.doc
        Dove: dove-d3p0-Fig33-27.JPG
        Dove: dove-d3p0-Fig33-28.JPG
        Koper: Koper, Ezra Figure 33-25-1 for subclause 33.6.vsd
        Landry: landry_33.2.6.1_v01.pdf
        Landry: landry_fig33-1-fig33-3_v01.pdf
        Landry: landry_fig33-9_v01.pdf
        Landry: landry_fig33-17_v02.pdf
        Nadeau: 802.3at Draft PICS v0.3.pdf
        Sastry: Collison detect behavior.pdf
        Sastry: Conserve mode in PD.pdf
        Stanford: comments 76 136 178 321.ppt
        Vetteth: vetteth_Fig_33-14.bmp


Comments received during Task Force review

D1.0

January 2008 Interim: Portland, OR

        All comments, sorted by clause
        All comments, sorted by ID

November 2007 Plenary: Atlanta, GA

        All comments, sorted by clause
        All comments, sorted by ID
        Open/Unresolved comments, sorted by clause

        Unresolved Buckets, sorted by clause:
            Resolved comments ready for signoff
            Annex
            Baseline text
            Cabling
            Editorial
            L1 adhoc
            Midspan
            State diagrams
            VPort adhoc
        All new comments, sorted by clause
        All new comments, sorted by ID
        New comments, in EZ bucket

Attachments

        all_files.tar.gz
        Darshan: Opt_Vport_lim Figure 33-6 rev 003.pdf
        Darshan: Updated figure 33-7.pdf
        Stanford: Figure 33-12c PD Requesting Power state diagram.jpg
        Stanford: Figure 33-7c-Type 2 PSE Classfication state diagram.jpg
        Stanford: Figure 33-7b PSE state diagram continued.jpg
        Stanford: Permutations table.doc

D0.9

October 2007 Interim: Richfield, OH

        All comments, sorted by clause
        Unclosed comments, sorted by clause

September 2007 Interim: Seoul, Korea

        All comments, sorted by clause
        Resolved comments, sorted by clause
        Unresolved comments, sorted by clause

        Unresolved Buckets, sorted by clause:
            33.2.7
            Annex
            Baseline
            Cable
            DLL
            Inrush
            Legacy
            SOA
            All the rest
        Partially resolved comments, sorted by clause
        Editor-annotated comments from D0.8 resolution, sorted by ID
        All new comments, sorted by clause
        All new comments, sorted by ID
        New comments, in EZ bucket

Attachments

        all_files.tar.gz
        Darshan: 2007-08-14_darshan_Figure 33C.6.1.vsd
        Darshan: Opt_Vport_lim Figure 33-6 rev 003.pdf
        Darshan: Part of figure 33-4a - Replace the following descriptio.doc
        Landry: P802d3at_D0p9_table_33d3.pdf
        Stanford: Type 2 Layer 1 PSE state diagram stanford.pdf
        Stanford: Type 2 Layer 2 PSE state diagram stanford.pdf
        Stanford: Type 2 Layer 2 PSE state diagram stanford revf 2.pdf

D0.8

July 2007 Plenary: San Francisco, CA

        All comments, sorted by comment ID
        Resolved comments, sorted by comment ID
        Unresolved comments, sorted by comment ID
        All new comments, sorted by clause
        All new comments, sorted by comment ID

Attachments

        all_files.tar.gz
        Barrass: L2_management.pdf
        Darshan: Figure 33-6 rev 002.pdf
        Darshan: Figure 33C.6.1.vsd
        Darshan: Replace the following descriptio.doc
        Law: P802p3at_fig_33d3.pdf
        Law: P802p3at_fig_33d4a.pdf
        Law: P802p3at_sub_33p3p5p2.pdf

Return to IEEE P802.3at Task Force Home Page
Last update: 29 July 2008

[Search] [e-mail] [Standards Home Page] [Corporate Home Page]