|Thread Links||Date Links|
|Thread Prev||Thread Next||Thread Index||Date Prev||Date Next||Date Index|
Tentative tally: Vote categories: DIS DNV APP ABS ------------------------------------------------- 01 Mat Sherman DIS 02 Pat Thaler DNV 03 Buzz Rigsbee APP 04 Bob O'Hara DIS (Will change based on Geoff's words) 05 John Hawkins DNV 06 Tony Jeffree APP 07 Bob Grow DIS (Will change based on Geoff's words) 08 Stuart Kerry DNV 09 Bob Heile DNV 10 Roger Marks DNV 11 Mike Takefman DNV APP 12 Mike Lynch DIS (Will change based on Geoff's words) 13 Steve Shellhammer DNV 14 Jerry Upton DNV 15 Ajay Rajkumar DNV 16 Carl Stevenson APP 17 Paul Nikolich APP ---++++---+++++---++++--- TOTALS DIS DNV APP ABS -16- total: -04- -09- -05- -00- Geoff's proposed wording is: "3. LMSC projects are balloted by individuals. An LMSC PAR specifying a balloting method other than balloting by individuals may be submitted to NesCom only when approved by the EC in a separate vote taken in session at an 802 plenary to approve the exceptional balloting method." Present situation is that all "DIS" would change to "APP based on Geoff's wording, with the exception of Mat, who has made this comment: "I will change my vote to approve if the following text is removed: 'unless approved in advance by a specific vote of the EC taken in session at an 802 plenary'." So, what Mat proposes is that the text should simply read: "3. LMSC projects are balloted by individuals. No LMSC PAR may be submitted to NesCom specifying any other method of sponsor balloting." His rationale is that, as the SA has no model P&P for running both individual and entity balloting, we could not operate an entity ballot within our current P&P, and therefore the question of whether or not the EC might vote to approve one is moot. I would like feedback on this - whether (a) Geoff's wording, or (b) Mat's simplified wording, will be more acceptable. Regards, Tony ---------- This email is sent from the 802 Executive Committee email reflector. This list is maintained by Listserv.
P&P clause 17 revision.doc