Re: [802SEC] 802 Chair's Guidelinesrevision 1.9
2.1: My understanding is that maintenance PARs do not require the 30-day
notice mentioned in footnote 3.
2.1: Why is there no footnote 1?
2.2: Is this ever used? I never heard of this before.
2.2.3.b: Why limit this to once?
2.2.7: Why limit this to 10?
2.3.5: Why a firm limit of 10?
2.4.9: What does "Exceptions: See EC Chair" mean? Does it mean that if
you want exceptions to see the EC Chair? Does it mean that there are
some unstated exceptions, and to see the EC Chair to find out what they
are? Does it mean that the EC Chair is excepted from receiving the CD?
Does it mean that there is supposed to be a section in this document
that was to be titled EC Chair, and some exceptions were to have been
2.6: (You really shouldn't have two numbered lists in one section.
Perhaps a subsection numbering should be used here to divide the two
lists into separate sections.)
2.6.3: What is "the chair’s $200 allocation"?
2.9, first occurrence: I though we had deprecated future use of this OID
arc in deference to org ieee(111)
2.9, second occurrence: You have two sections numbered 2.9
2.12.1: I think that "that details the URLs the Patent Policy, Patent
FAQ, Affiliations FAQ, Antitrust guidelines, and Ethics policy" should
be changed by adding "of" after "URLs" to read "that details the URLs of
the Patent Policy, Patent FAQ, Affiliations FAQ, Antitrust guidelines,
and Ethics policy".
2.12.4: Why are these "Suggest[ed]"? Are there alternative URLs that one
might use instead?
On 8/20/2008 1:11 PM, Paul Nikolich wrote:
With the correct attachment this time.
----- Original Message ----- From: "Paul Nikolich"
Sent: Wednesday, August 20, 2008 3:40 PM
Subject: 802 Chair's Guidelinesrevision 1.9
Dear EC members,
Attached is revision 1.9 of the 802 Chair's Guidelines. This is a long
overdue action item on my part. Other than several editorial changes,
main changes are the addition of items 2.11 and 2.12.
2.11 Chair's guidelines regarding cross WG and TAG document and E-mail
2.12 Chair's guidelines regarding Patent Policy announcement
In order to make the editorial changes obvious, I left revision marks
everything except the 2.11 and 2.12 additions and format changes.
Barring any objections (that include constructive criticism with
for specific changes), I will replace the revision 1.8 Guideline with
revision 1.9 Guideline on Saturday 6SEP2008.
This email is sent from the 802 Executive Committee email reflector.
This list is maintained by Listserv.
This email is sent from the 802 Executive Committee email reflector. This list is maintained by Listserv.