[802SEC] Procedure 13 report for IEEE P802.3bc Ethernet Organizationally Specific type, length, values (TLVs) to Sponsor Ballot

[David Law <David_Law@3COM.COM>]

Dear EC members,

At the March 2009 IEEE 802 Plenary meeting conditional approval was 
granted to forward IEEE P802.3bc Ethernet Organizationally Specific type, 
length, values (TLVs) to Sponsor Ballot. Details are provide in the 
attached report but in summary the response to the Clause 13 ‘Procedure 
for Conditional Approval to Forward a Draft Standard’ items are as 
follows:

a) The recirculation balloting is complete. The
   first recirculation ballot and comment resolution
   occurred essentially in accordance of the plan
   presented.

   A second recirculation was however required that
   was not present in the plan presented in March.

b) The approval rate after resolution of the ballot is 
   greater than 75% and there were no new negative
   DISAPPROVES votes.

c) No technical changes have been made.

d) There were no new valid DISAPPROVE comments.

e) There was one new DISAPPROVE comments ruled invalid
   by the WG chair.

   Despite the comment being ruled invalid the substance
   of the comment was discussed during the comment
   resolution meeting. Full details are provided in
   the attached report.

Based on the above I plan to open the sponsor ballot on Tuesday 9th June.

Best regards,
David Law
IEEE 802.3 Working Group Chair

Attachment: IEEE802d3bc_proc13_report_V1p1.pdf
Description: Binary data