Date: Mon, 10 Jun 1996 11:33:16 -0700
From: hendel@uask4it-223.Eng.Sun.COM ( Ariel Hendel)
To: jlarson@fnal.gov, p8021@hepnrc.hep.net
Subject: 802.1p/D3 Ballot


SUBJECT:  P802.1p/D3 - Traffic Class and Dynamic Multicast Filtering 
          Services in Bridged LANs


__X__ I disapprove for the following reasons.


        ARIEL HENDEL

----------------------------------------------------------------------

MAIN OBJECTION:
In my opinion the value of 802.1p is strongly dependent on the ability
of upper layers to perform admission control, or equivalent bandwidth
management functions. I would like to make sure that 802.1p approval is
done once the feasibility of interfacing these functions to 802.1p is
shown, and any necessary mechanisms to assist it are considered.



TECHNICAL COMMENTS:

Section 2.6.6, page 14, lines 20-24
Filtering Mode 2, sub mode B. This mode filters all unregistered
Multicast and Unicast addresses. I believe that filtering unregistered
Unicasts is not desirable.