IEEE P802.11
Wireless LANs
Report of Ballot on IEEE P802.11 D3
Date:	March 6, 1996
Author:	Vic Hayes, Chair IEEE P802.11
	Lucent Technologies
	Zadelstede 1-10
	Phone: +31 30 609 7528
	Fax: +31 30 609 7555
	e-Mail: vic.hayes@wcnd.ns-nl.att.com
The statement:
“I approve the IEEE P802.11 proposed draft standard P802.11/D2 to be forwarded for sponsor ballot”
was defeated with the following result:

Ballot result
Of the voting members the result is 42 approving and 18 not approving.  That is a support of 70 % (75 % is needed).

The complete result is as follows:
Memebr type	Do not approve	Approve	Grand Total	
Aspirant members	0	1	1	
Nearly Voting members	1	0	1	
Regulator.	1	0	1	
Voting members	18	42	60	
Grand Total	19	42	61	

The ballot is valid because 81.1 % of the voting members (we had 74 voting membersat the beginning of the ballot) returned their ballot. (50 % is required)

The “vote” from the Regulator is the comment I received as result of the review of draft D3.0 by  the Japanese Ministry of Post and Telecommunications.  (code kaf)  I sponsor his input as negative comments to our ballot, because I find compatibility with the Japanese market very important.

I have also added the comments from the IEEE editor, Valerie Zalente.  (code vz)

Comments
I have made the best effort to consolidate the comments into a set of documents with document numbers consisting of the number and a sequence number.  This document is -1, -2 is the general comment, comment on the foreword, title pages and so on and on the annexes. -3 is on clauses 1-6, -4 is on clauses 7-8, -5 is on clause 9, -6 is on clause 10-11 and -7 is on clauses 12-16 (the PHY part).

The comments have been sorted on section number.  I have left the Sequence number empty for the use of the editors of the documents for the comment resolution.

Tables with votes and with initials
The remainder of this document shows the vote per individual.  I have also provided a list with the initials used in the tables for the source of comments, both sorted on last name and on initials.

Please let me know if your comments were not correctly represented in this document.

title_firstname	lastname	Initials	vote	comment	relation	phone	fax	e_mail	
Mr. DAVID	BAGBY	db	n	y	Voter	+1 408 749 5425	+1 408 774 8446	david.bagby@amd.com	
Mr. C. THOMAS	BAUMGARTNER	tb	n	y	Voter	+1 847 317 1770	+1 847 317 1517	ctb8@aol.com	
Mr. PHIL	BELANGER	pb	y		Voter				
Mr. MANUEL J.	BETANCOR	mb	y		Voter	+34 28 451272	+34 28 451243	betancor@deimos.ulpgc.es	
Mr. SIMON	BLACK	sb	y	y	Voter	+44 1223 421025	+44 1223 421031	sab@symbionics.co.uk	
Mr. JAN	BOER	jb	n	y	Voter	+31 3060 97483	+31 3060 97555	jan.boer@att.com	
Mr. ALESSANDRO M.	BOLEA	amb	y	y	Voter	+1 508 490 1857	+1 508 490 1563	amb@sud2.ed.ray.com	
Mr. PABLO	BRENNER	pb	y		Voter	+972 3 6459127	+972 3 645 9191	pablo@lannet.com	
Mr. PETER E.	CHADWICK	pc	y		Voter	+44 1793 518080	+44 1793 518318	gecp.peterc@applelink.apple.com	
Mr. NAFTALI	CHAYAT	nc	y		Voter	+972 3 645 9195	+972 3 645 9191	naftali@lannet.com	
Dr. JONATHON Y.	CHEAH	jyc	n	y	Voter	+1 619 450 1220 X3069	+1 619 457 2681	jcheah@airlan.com	
Dr. KWANG-CHENG	CHEN	kc	x		Voter	+886 35 715131 x4054	+886 35 715971	chenkc@ee.nthu.edu.tw	
Dr. HAE WOOK	CHOI	hc	y		Voter	+82 42 860 6841	+82 42 860 6200	hwchoi@cadvax.etri.re.kr	
Mr. MARK	DEMANGE	md	x		Voter	+1 708 576 7913	+1 708 538 5391	mark_demange@wes.mot.com	
Mr. WIM	DIEPSTRATEN	wd	n	y	Voter	+31 3060 97482	+31 3060 97555	wim.diepstraten@att.com	
Mr. ROBERT J.	EGAN	re	y		Voter			bobe@ids.net	
Mr. GREG	ENNIS	ge	y	y	Voter	+1 408 358 5544	+1 408 358 5541	gennis@netcom.com	
Mr. JOHN	FAKATSELIS	jf	y		Voter	+1 407 729 4733	+1 407 724 7094	jfakat01@ccmail.mis.semi.harris.com	
Mr. MATTHEW	FISCHER	maf	n	y	Voter	+1 408 749 5403	+1 408 774 8449	ablmatt@brahms.amd.com	
Mr. MICHAEL	FISCHER	mif	n	y	Voter	+1 210 614 4096	+1 210 614 8192	mfischer@child.com	
Mr. ROLAND	FOURNIER	rf	y		Voter	+1 408 749 5439	+1 408 774 8446	roland.fournier@amd.com	
Kazushige	Fujita	kaf	n	y	Regul.				
Mr. KEITH S.	FURUYA	kf	y		Voter	+1 408 922 9053	+1 408 954 1309	Keith.Furuya@fmi.fujitsu.com	
Mr. ED	GEIGER	eg	x		Voter	+1 408 974 4907	+1 408 974 9793	edg@apple.com	
Mr. IAN	GIFFORD	ig	y		Voter	+1 508 442 4650	+1 508 442 4600	giffordi@corp.macom.com	
Mr. HOWARD J.	HALL	hh	y		Voter	+1 508 952 0170 X345	+1 508 952 0168	howardh@wireless.windata.com	
Mr. VICTOR	HAYES	vh	n	y	Voter	+31 3060 97528	+31 3060 97555	vic.hayes@att.com	
Ms. CAROLYN L.	HEIDE	ch	n	y	Voter	+1 847 317 1770	+1 847 317 1517	71041.3262@compuserve.com	
Mr. DAVID TAL	HELLER	dth	x		Voter	+972 2 6519311/3	+972 2 6519314	davidh@rdc.active.net.il	
Mr. BRADLEY	HERRIN	brh	x		Voter	+1 714 707 2376	+1 714 707 2434	bradley.herrin@smc.com	
Mr. BILL	HUHN	bih	y		Voter	+1 216 665 7352	+1 216 665 7922	bhuhn@aironet.com	
Mr. DONALD C.	JOHNSON	dj	x		Voter	+1 513 445 1452	+1 513 445 1441	donald.c.johnson@daytonoh.attgis.com	
Mr. DEAN M.	KAWAGUCHI	dk	y		Voter	+1 408 369 2629	+1 408 369 2740	deank@psd.symbol.com	
Mr. STUART	KERRY	sk	y		Voter	+1 408 369 2634	+1 408 446 4630	stuart@psd.symbol.com	
Mr. MIKIO	KIYONO	mk	y		Voter	+1 415 528 5901	+1 415 528 5900	mikio@ccgate.sj.nec.com	
Mr. JOSEPH J.	KUBLER	jjk	n	y	Voter	+1 303 442 1850	+1 303 442 1850	kublerj@norand.com	
Ms. ISABEL	LIN	il	x		Voter	+1 714 583 3854	+1 714 583 3893	isabell@tais.com	
Mr. FRANCISCO J.	LOPEZ-HERNANDEZ	fl	y		Voter	+34 1 336 73 41	+34 1 336 7319	dxtn@tfo.upm.es	
Mr. JERRY	LORAINE	jl	x		Voter	+44 1223 421025	+44 1223 421031	jl@symbionics.co.uk	
Mr. RONALD	MAHANY	rm	n	y	Voter	+1 319 369 3552	+1 319 369 5534	mahanyrl@norand.com	
Mr. BOB	MARSHALL	bm	x		Voter	+1 408 991 2722	+1 408 991 4800	marshall@scs.philips.com	
Mr. JIM	McDONALD	jim	y		Voter	+1 708 576 3169	+1 708 576 0892	jim_mcdonald@wes.mot.com	
Dr. AKIRA	MIURA	akm	y		Voter	+1 415 858 1000	+1 415 493 1930	miura@tadw.research.panasonic.com	
Mr. ADRIANO J.	MOREIRA	ajm	y		Voter	+351 34 381937	+351 34 381941	adriano@ua.pt	
Mr. WAYNE D.	MOYERS	wm	y		Voter	+1 408 338 7562	+1 408 338 7562	wmoyers@wise.com	
Mr. BOB	O'HARA	bo	n	y	Voter	+1 408 749 4952	+1 408 774 8447	bob.ohara@amd.com	
Mr. MITSUJI	OKADA	mo	y		Voter	+1 415 965 6549	+1 415 965 6264	mokada@asic.mtv.nec.com	
Mr. AL	PETRICK	ap	y		Voter	+1 407 729 4944	+1 407 724 7094	apetrick@ccmail.mis.semi.harris.com	
Ms. MIRI	RATNER	mra	y		Voter	+972 3 6459134	+972 3 645 9191	mirir@lannet.com	
Mr. JAMES A.	RENFRO	jar	y		Voter	+1 508 490 1934	+1 508 490 1563	james_a_renfro@ccmail.ed.ray.com	
Mr. JON WALTER	ROSDAHL	jwr	y		Voter	+1 801 429 3183	+1 801 429 7232	JON_ROSDAHL@novell.com	
Mr. MICHAEL	ROTHENBERG	mro	y		Voter	+972 3 6458423	+972 3 645 9191	mrot@lannet.com	
Mr. CHANDOS	RYPINSKI	cr	n	y	Voter	+1 415 389 6659	+1 415 389 6746	rypinski@netcom.com	
Mr. ANIL K.	SANWALKA	as	n	y	Voter	+1 416 724 8127	+1 416 724 8128	anil@interlog.com	
Mr. ERAN	SHPAK	es	n	y	Nearly V	+972 9 982606	+972 9 983218	airaxs@netvision.net.il	
Mr. THOMAS	SIEP	tsi	y		Voter	+1 214 995 3675	+1 214 995 6194	siep@ti.com	
Mr. NATHAN	SILBERMAN	ns	y		Voter	+1 408 565 5143		snathan@ix.netcom.com	
Mr. DON	SLOAN	dos	y		Voter	+1 216 665 7917	+1 216 665 7301	dons@aironet.com	
Mr. GREG	SMITH	gs	y		Voter	+44 1522 502476		smith_g@lincoln.gpsemi.com	
Mr. MARVIN	SOJKA	mso	y		Voter	+1 216 665 7918	+1 216 665 7355	msojk@telxon.com	
Mr. JOHN	SONNENBERG	js	x		Voter	+1 619 674 8360	+1 619 674 8373	johnsonnenberg@pulseeng.com	
Dr. WALTER C.	SOTELO	ws	y		aspirant	+1 408 654 2052	+1 408 492 1982	walters@fsba.com	
Mr. MACK	SULLIVAN	msu	n	y	Voter	+1 415 960 1630	+1 415 960 1984	mack@proxim.com	
Mr. MIKE	TROMPOWER	mt	y		Voter	+1 216 665 7920	+1 216 665 7301	mtrom@aironet.com	
Mr. TOM	TSOULOGIANNIS	tt	n	y	Voter	+1 416 299 1954	+1 416 299 3714	tomt@interlog.com	
Mr. RYAN H.	TZE	rt	x		Voter	+1 714 587 6769	+1 714 583 3893	ryant@tais.com	
Mr. RUI	VALADAS	rv	y		Voter				
Ms. JEANINE	VALADEZ	jv	y		Voter	+1 408 749 5206	+1 408 774 8448	jeanine.valadez@amd.com	
Mr. SAROSH	VESUNA	sv	y		Voter	+1 408 369 2657	+1 408 369 2740	saroshv@psd.symbol.com	
Mr. HIROHISA	WAKAI	hw	y		Voter	81 7436 5 2466	'+81 7436 5 2163	wakai@shpcsl.sharp.co.jp	
Mr. RICHARD E.	WHITE	rw	n	y	Voter	+1 708 435 0235	+1 708 576 7907	white_rick@macmail2.cig.mot.com	
Mr. STEPHEN	WOOD	sw	x		Voter	+1 214 952 1139	+1 214 952 1189	swood@AEP-MAIN-PO1.ANDREW.sprint.com	
Mr. IWEN	YAO	iy	y		Voter	+1 508 256 4950	+1 508 256 5120		
Mr. RALPH C.	YEAGER	ry	x		Voter	+1 919 543 3779	+1 919 543 7378	ralphy@vnet.ibm.com	
Mr. CHRIS	ZEGELIN	cz	y		Voter	+1 408 369 2667	+1 408 369 2740	chrisz@psd.symbol.com	
Ms. Valerie	Zelenty	vz			IEEE				
Mr. LAWRENCE H.	ZUCKERMAN	lz	x		Voter	+1 408 263 6300 X288	+1 408 263 6571	zuckerman@imicorp.com $	
Mr. JOHNNY	ZWEIG	jz	n	y	Voter	+1 415 691 2500	+1 415 691 1064	jzweig@xircom.com