Hello Carol,
Here are your allocations:
As I noted below you would need a WG motion for Element IDs (although they seem to duplicate extension elements).
Your task group needs a technical solution to the frame subtype problem.
You request values 90 and 91 for Extended Capabilities, but these are already taken by 11az.
-Robert
From: Stacey, Robert
Sent: Friday, November 5, 2021 10:15 AM
To: Carol Ansley <carol@xxxxxxxxxx>
Cc: Marc Emmelmann <marc.emmelmann@xxxxxxxxxx>; Marc Emmelmann <emmelmann@xxxxxxxx>
Subject: RE: ANA Requests for TGbc
Hello Carol,
There are some issues with your request.
- Based on your draft, I think you are looking for a Data frame subtype allocation and not a Frame Type allocation. However, there are no Data frame subtypes available – all have been
allocated. You might want to look into using the Extension frame type.
- Element ID allocations require a WG motion to approve. There are very few left and they are reserved for special needs, for example, 11ad used one because the beacon size was critical
(Element IDs are one byte shorter than Element ID Extensions). So, unless you really really need one byte less I would just go for an Element ID Extension.
The rest I think I can accommodate.
-Robert
Below are the TGbc ANA requests. I had filled in some numbers based on earlier drafts, but feel free to correct them. Also please let me know if you see problems with any of these requests.
Regards,
Carol
|
Type of Request
|
Resource Name
|
Item Name
|
Item Description
|
Requested Value (if any)
|
Requested by Task Group
|
Requested by Name
|
|
Allocate
|
FrameTypes
|
|
EBCS Data (Table 9-1)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
ElementIDs
|
|
EBCS Parameters element (Table 9-32)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
ElementIDs
|
|
EBCS TIM (Table 9-32)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
ElementIDs
|
|
EBCS Parameters element (Table 9-41)
|
112
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
Element ID Extension 1
|
|
EBCS Parameters (Table 9-92)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
Element ID Extension 1
|
|
EBCS TIM (Table 9-92)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
Info IDs
|
Enhanced Broadcast Services
|
(table 9-331)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
Info IDs
|
Enhanced Broadcast Services Request
|
(table 9-331)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
Info IDs
|
Enhanced Broadcast Service Response
|
(table 9-331)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
dot11StationConfigEntry
|
dot11EBCSSupportActivated
|
(C.3 MIB)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
dot11StationConfigEntry
|
dot11EBCSContentList
|
(C.3 MIB)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
dot11StationConfigEntry
|
dot11EBCSInfoInterval
|
(C.3 MIB)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
dot11StationConfigEntry
|
dot11EBCSHCFAKeyChangeInterval
|
(C.3 MIB)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
dot11StationConfigEntry
|
dot11EBCSHCFAHashDistance
|
(C.3 MIB)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
dot11StationConfigEntry
|
dot11EBCSInfoTxRate
|
(C.3 MIB)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
dot11StationConfigEntry
|
dot11EBCSDTIMPeriod
|
(C.3 MIB)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
dot11StationConfigEntry
|
dot11EBCSTerminationNoticeTime
|
(C.3 MIB)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
dot11StationConfigEntry
|
dot11EBCSTermination NoticeMinimumInterval
|
(C.3 MIB)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
dot11StationConfigEntry
|
dot11EBCSTermination NoticeMaximumInterval
|
(C.3 MIB)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
dot11StationConfigEntry
|
dot11EBCSRelayingServiceSupported
|
(C.3 MIB)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
dot11Groups
|
dot11EBCSComplianceGroup
|
(C.3 MIB)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
dot11Compliances
|
dot11EBCSCompliance
|
(C.3 MIB)
|
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
ExtendedCapabilities
|
EBCS Support
|
(Table 9-153)
|
90
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
|
Allocate
|
ExtendedCapabilities
|
EBCS Relaying Supported
|
(Table 9-153)
|
91
|
TGbc
|
Carol Ansley
|
To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-11-EDITORS list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-EDITORS&A=1