| Thread Links | Date Links | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thread Prev | Thread Next | Thread Index | Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index |
|
Oh, no thank you Stephen… I thought the TTTs were to get interested parties to focus on the comment group in an effort to achieve consensus and then that consensus would be brought back to the larger group. That’s not what the PAKE TTT apparently is. The PAKE
TTT is the entire group, so it’s not even really a TTT, is it? You told me in a private conversation last month that you were the POC for the PAKE TTT but I don’t recall ever seeing an email to the reflector telling everyone of that fact before this one you just sent. And in the chat today you said
3 POCs have been assigned for other comment groups. Really? Guess I missed that email too. In a highly unscientific survey I did after the meeting no one else recalls seeing any announcement of which comment groups have POCs assigned nor who those POCs actually
are. So it’s not just me. But now you have stated that you’re the POC for the PAKE TTT (although your reasoning is a tad disingenuous as I stated to you up front that I did not think it would be appropriate for me to be the POC, so my email tone has nothing
to do with why you selected yourself). Can you tell us who the other POCs are and what comment groups they are POCs for? Then maybe some progress on getting consensus in those comment groups can be achieved.
And I thought it was clear, the email thread I started was not to come to consensus but to list the features a PAKE can have that we need to come to consensus on! It was an effort to get the discussion on track. There was no attempt to
get consensus on any of the features, just to get agreement on the features that need consensus. And I think that was achieved. Sorry you don’t find any value in that effort and did not view that as a constructive effort. I will step back then and defer to
your guidance on how the group should proceed. So what is your plan? When can you share it with the group?
Your right. My submissions have not gained positive momentum. Neither have any of the other ones that other people have been repeatedly presenting in past sessions. So what’s the point of presenting them over again? I don’t know? Like
I said, I’ll defer to you on how to come to consensus but if we’re gonna go over someone else’s old submission again then I’m just asking for the same consideration to be given to me. Whether the week is a “waste” or not… I guess it will depend on whether we have made any progress come Friday. If all we did was repeat presentations that have, as you note, not gained positive momentum when presented in the past then
I’m not sure what else to conclude. But maybe this time it’ll be different! Regards, Dan. -- “the object of life is not to be on the side of the majority, but to escape finding oneself in the ranks of the insane.” – Marcus Aurelius On 11/9/26, 10:40 AM, "Stephen Orr (sorr)" <sorr@xxxxxxxxx> wrote: Thanks Dan, Its 100% because of emails of this nature that deter people from participating and the reason why I am the PoC for this group. The TTT’s are for anyone to participate and not exclude others. Now if we look at the email thread you started over the last two weeks -
even that small group couldn’t come to consensus. Your submissions that have been presented multiple times have yet to gain positive momentum. If you find the meetings a waste - please feel free to direct your time elsewhere, otherwise focus on being constructive and trying to work
with the larger team. Stephen To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-11-TGBT list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-TGBT&A=1 |