Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

Re: [STDS-802-11-TGBT] cross-reference discussion



Hello all,

For what it's worth, I've found it easier to review PAKE submissions that reference an Internet-Draft such as draft-vos-cfrg-pqpake. Doing so makes it easier to see which features are used from the referenced drafts, and which parts are protocol additions specific to 802.11. It also avoids having to double-check whether parts that were copied from the Internet-Draft are indeed accurately described, that there are no accidental deviations, and it forces the submission to explicitly mention where there are purposeful deviations. So at least from a 'submission review perspective', this is useful.

I'd even say that if the group decides to specify entirely in 11bt, then it may still help to (first) have a version that references Internet-Drafts (at least if there are only a small number of deviations from the referenced draft). The referenced parts can be directly specified (and reviewed) as a subsequent step.

Best regards,
Mathy

From: Stephen Orr (sorr) <000015666257037f-dmarc-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Sent: 10 November 2026 21:48
To: STDS-802-11-TGBT@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx <STDS-802-11-TGBT@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Subject: Re: [STDS-802-11-TGBT] cross-reference discussion
 
Thanks Yanjun

Appreciate the background

Today we should be able to get some direction from the group on whether we specify CPaceOQuake entirely in 11bt or reference the IRTF submission



-- 
Stephen Orr

 


From: Yanjun Sun <yanjunsunstd@xxxxxxxxx>
Date: Tuesday, November 10, 2026 at 04:35
To: STDS-802-11-TGBT@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx <STDS-802-11-TGBT@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Subject: Re: [STDS-802-11-TGBT] cross-reference discussion

FYI, after checking the IEEE SA Standards Style Manual, it looks that there are some guidelines.

12.3 Normative references
12.3.1 What is a normative reference?
In an IEEE standard normative references are those documents that contain material that must be
understood and used to implement the standard.13 Thus, normative references are indispensable when
applying the standard. The decision to include something as a normative reference in a standard should be
made thoughtfully. Documents to which reference is made only for information or background, and
documents that served merely as references in the preparation of the standard, are not normative references.
Such documents may, however, be included in a bibliography. (See Clause 19.)
Normative references may include the following:
a) Standards: IEEE standards and standards developed by other recognized standards developing
organizations (SDOs) are the preferred source of normative references.
b) Non-standards documents: A document that is not a standard may be cited provided that:
 It is judged by the balloting group to have wide acceptance and authoritative status.
 It is publicly available at reasonable cost.
 The reference includes the edition or date of publication
Be aware that non-standards documents may prove problematic because they might be revised
without notice in a manner that might adversely affect the standard in which it is normatively
referenced.
c) Draft standards: Unpublished drafts may be used as normative references as long as they are:
 Dated
 Readily available
 Retrievable
A copy of ALL drafts shall be submitted to IEEE SA to be placed on file as an archive. Note that if
a referenced IEEE draft is approved prior to publication of the document, the draft reference will be
updated to reflect this change during the publication process. If the working groups prefers that the
draft reference remain as is, the citation shall be followed by “(this version).”

Thanks,
Yanjun

On Nov 10, 2026, at 3:14 PM, Harkins, Dan <00003862fd143b8a-dmarc-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

 
  Hi Jay,
 
  You don’t get to just say what we can do when you, in fact, just learned about this issue about 2 hours ago. You can’t possibly speak authoritatively on the matter. A straw poll doesn’t change anything. Sorry you don’t want to have a back and forth but then don’t just declare that I’m wrong and we can do what you want.
 
  I think the prudent course of action will be to do nothing at this point since we don’t need to have any reference to draft-vos AT THIS POINT IN TIME. It’s still and individual submission, it has no status really. Let’s wait until we get an official  response from the IETF-IEEE liaison who can bring it up with the relevant parties who know and care about this stuff. Maybe it’ll be OK, maybe it won’t.
 
  By the way, how many Internet-Drafts have you been affiliated with that got held up by the IESG due to a downref issue? I’ll wager that it is zero.
 
  Dan.
 
--
“the object of life is not to be on the side of the majority, but to
escape finding oneself in the ranks of the insane.” – Marcus Aurelius
 
 
On 11/10/26, 2:58 PM, "Jay Yang" <yang.zhijie@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
 
Hi Dan,
 
Thanks for the quick response.
 
The short answer is we can  normatively  refer to the draft based on the cross-reference rule defined in RFC 7241.
I don't want to have a back and forth discussion in the reflector; perhaps we need a SP on this tomorrow.
 
Thanks you for the good discussion.
 
杨志杰10343608
 
Thanks
 
Best Regards
 
Jay Yang (杨志杰)
 
 
Original
From: Harkins,Dan <daniel.harkins@xxxxxxx>  
To: 杨志杰10343608;  
Date: 2026年11月10日 15:48  
Subject: Re: cross-reference discussion  
 
  Yes, I believe you are mistaken. It is an issue. A blocker? No, it just means we can’t *normatively* refer to the draft, we can refer to it informatively as a “work in progress” though. I don’t see that as an issue. If you think  it’s an issue then we need to specify the key exchange more fully in the TGbt draft as I have done in 11-26/0089r8.
 
  As a bit of history, about 15 years ago I was sent to ISO meetings to deal with a Chinese protocol called WAPI which the China National Body was trying to push in ISO as an “international standard”. As part of their effort to lift up  WAPI, they also tried to drag down 802.11 with spurious claims about insecurity. When their claims were all addressed they finally responded with a challenge that 802.11 was invalid because it was normatively referring to several Informational RFCs. We had  to educate them about the downref procedure and that the normative references at the time had all been given exceptions by the IETF and they then withdrew that complaint. So it seems to me the last thing we, 802.11, want to do is give any more ammunition to  these rogue national bodies in ISO which continue to vote negatively in ISO ballots to approve our 802.11 standard and various amendments as “international standards”.
 
  Dan.
 
--
“the object of life is not to be on the side of the majority, but to
escape finding oneself in the ranks of the insane.” – Marcus Aurelius
 
On 11/10/26, 2:39 PM, "yang.zhijie@xxxxxxxxxx" <yang.zhijie@xxxxxxxxxx>  wrote:
 
Hi Dan,
 
Thanks for the discussion on Downref registry. I copy the link here you provided during the F2F discussion this afternoon.
Based on my understanding,  it's IETF/IRTF the internal procedure, nothing relevant to 802.11 referring to the I-D of PQC PAKE protocol.
I will leave the author of PQC PAKE protocol in CFRG to have a look at this. (e.g. clarify an RFC refer to informational I-D as TLS did if  PQC PAKE protocol becomes an RFC ahead of its references), maybe Peter can have some talk with the author to see how to handle it.
But it's not a block issue for us.
 
Please feel free to correct me if I make any mistake. Welcome the further insight.
 
 
 
image001.png
 
image002.png
 
 
杨志杰10343608
 
Thanks
 
Best Regards
 
Jay Yang (杨志杰)
 
 
 
 

To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-11-TGBT list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-TGBT&A=1


To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-11-TGBT list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-TGBT&A=1



To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-11-TGBT list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-TGBT&A=1


To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-11-TGBT list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-TGBT&A=1


To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-11-TGBT list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-TGBT&A=1