IEEE 802.16 Letter Ballot #15: Ballot Report

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Recirculation Ballot #15a: Announcement {CLOSED}

• Question: To accept the resolutions of comments from Working Group Recirculation Ballot #15a, as recorded in IEEE 802.16-04/64r2 and to forward, to the IEEE 802 LMSC Executive Committee, IEEE 802.16-04/56r1 (Draft PAR and Five Criteria for an IEEE 802.16 Project on License-Exempt Coexistence).
• Closing date: 30 October 2004 AOE ("Anywhere on Earth")
• Opening date: 15 October 2004
• Ballot Submission Form
• Output Database IEEE 802.16-04/64r4 (One new comment: Comment 23, including response)

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #15: Announcement {CLOSED}

• Question: To forward, to the IEEE 802 LMSC Executive Committee, IEEE 802.16-04/56 (Draft PAR and Five Criteria for an IEEE 802.16 Project on License-Exempt Coexistence).
• Closing date: 22 September 2004 AOE ("Anywhere on Earth")
• Opening date: 7 September 2004
• Ballot Submission Form

Summary Results

Ballot Details

Name\Family	Name\Given	Letter Ballot #15	Recirc Ballot #15a
Agis	Edward	Approve, No Comments
Agrawal	Aditya	Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Al-Dabagh	Baraa	Approve, No Comments
Aliotta	Mario	Approve, No Comments
Andelman	Dov	Approve, No Comments
Antonello	Gordon	Approve, No Comments
Athalye	Sanjeev	Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Avivi	Eli	Approve, No Comments
Banerjea	Raja	Approve, No Comments
Banister	Brian	-
Barber	Phillip	Approve, Comments
Baum	Kevin	Approve, No Comments
Bentov	Izhar	-
Bhalla	Rajesh	-
Cai	Sean	Approve, No Comments
Castelow	David	Approve, No Comments
Cavalli	Giulio	Approve, No Comments
Chang	Dean	Approve, No Comments
Chang	Jae Hwan	Approve, No Comments
Chang	Yong	-
Chayat	Naftali	Approve, No Comments
Chayer	RŽmi	Approve, Comments
Chindapol	Aik	Approve, No Comments
Cho	Jaeweon	Approve, No Comments
Cho	Seokheon	Approve, No Comments
Choi	Hyoung-Jin	Approve, No Comments
Chou	Joey	Approve, No Comments
Chung	Jin Yong	Approve, No Comments
Costa	Jose	Approve, No Comments
Cudak	Mark	Approve, No Comments
Draper	Frank	Approve, No Comments
Dring	John	Approve, No Comments
Eastwood	Lester	Approve, No Comments
Eidson	Brian	Approve, No Comments
Eklund	Carl	Disapprove
Eliaspur	Yigal	Approve, No Comments
Eline	Roger	Approve, No Comments
Elkayam	Oren	Approve, No Comments
Fong	Mo-Han	Approve, No Comments
Franovici	Bogdan	Approve, No Comments
Freedman	Avraham	Approve, No Comments	Approve, Comments
Goldhamer	Mariana	Approve, No Comments
Golshan	Reza	Approve, No Comments
Guo	Qiang	Approve, No Comments
Hadad	Zion	Approve, No Comments
Hahn	Yung	Approve, No Comments
Han	Jun	Approve, No Comments
Hartman	David	-
Haskin	John	Approve, No Comments
Hwang	Seung Ku	Approve, No Comments
Iyer	Prakash	Approve, No Comments
Jeong	Moo Ryong	Approve, No Comments
Johnson	Brian	Approve, No Comments
Johnston	David	Disapprove**	Approve, No Comments
Joo	Panyuh	Approve, No Comments
Kaitz	Tal	Approve, No Comments
Kelman	Ofer	Approve, No Comments
Kerr	Adam	Approve, No Comments
Kiernan	Brian	Approve, No Comments
Kim	Jeonghwi	Approve, No Comments
Kim	Jung Won	-
Kim	Yong Bum	Approve, No Comments
Kim	YoungKyun	-
Kitroser	Itzik	Approve, No Comments
Koo	Changhoi	Approve, No Comments
Kotecha	Lalit	Approve, No Comments
Kulick	John	-
Kwon	Dongseung	Approve, No Comments
LaBrecque	Margaret	Approve, No Comments
Labs	Jonathan	Approve, No Comments
Lamoureux	Jules Pierre	Approve, No Comments
Lee	Chang-jae	Approve, No Comments
Lee	Jae Hak	Approve, No Comments
Lee	Seong Choon	Approve, No Comments
Leiba	Yigal	Approve, No Comments
Leimer	Donald	-
Lewis	Barry	Approve, No Comments
Li	Lingjie	-
Li	Xiaodong	Approve, No Comments
Liebetreu	John	Approve, No Comments
Lim	Geunhwi	Approve, No Comments
Lim	Hyoungsoo	Approve, No Comments
Lim	Yong Je	-
Lindskog	Erik	Approve, No Comments
Lo	Titus	Approve, No Comments
Lou	Hui-Ling	Approve, No Comments
Lycklama	Heinz	Approve, No Comments
Lynch	Michael	Approve, No Comments
Lysejko	Martin	Approve, No Comments
Maeng	Seung Joo	Approve, No Comments
Maez	David	-
Mandin	Jeffrey	Approve, No Comments
Mankin	Kevin	Approve, No Comments
Marks	Roger	Disapprove**	Approve, No Comments
McCallum	Ian	Approve, No Comments
Mckown	Russell	Approve, No Comments
Migaldi	Scott	Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Mollenauer	James	Approve, No Comments
Moon	Dong-Il (Stephan)	Approve, No Comments
Murias	Ronald	Approve, No Comments
Nelson	Robert	Approve, No Comments
Nitsche	Gunnar	Approve, No Comments
Odlyzko	Paul	Approve, No Comments
Olfat	Masoud	Approve, No Comments
Ovadia	Shlomo	Approve, No Comments
Park	Nam Hoon	Approve, No Comments
Park	Pyung-Su	Approve, No Comments
Park	Youn Ok	-
Pearman	Trevor	Approve, No Comments
Petrus	Paul	Approve, No Comments
Phillips	Greg	Approve, No Comments
Puthenkulam	Jose	Disapprove**	Approve, No Comments
Rath	Kamlesh	Approve, No Comments
Riegel	Maximilian	Approve, No Comments
Rogers	Chris	Approve, No Comments
Ryu	Byung-Han	Approve, No Comments
Ryu	Kiseon	Approve, No Comments
Sago	Andrew	Approve, No Comments
Salvekar	Atul	Approve, No Comments
Schwartz	Randall	Approve, No Comments
Segal	Yossi	Approve, No Comments
Selea	Radu	Approve, No Comments
Shakouri	Mohammad	Approve, No Comments
Shankaranarayanan	N.K.	Approve, Comments
Shasha	Eli	Approve, No Comments
Simkins	James	Approve, No Comments
Son	Jung Je	Approve, No Comments
Son	Yeong Moon	Approve, No Comments
Stanwood	Kenneth	Approve, No Comments
Stevenson	Carl	Approve, Comments
Taylor	Shawn	-
Tong	Wen	Approve, No Comments
Trinkwon	David	-
Ullmann	Rainer	Approve, No Comments
Vafai	Mano	-
Verbin	Eyal	Approve, No Comments
Vook	Frederick	Approve, No Comments
Wang	Arthur	Approve, No Comments
Wang	Irving	Approve, No Comments
Wang	Jing	Approve, No Comments
Wang	Lei	Approve, No Comments
Wang	Stanley	-
Whitehead	Philip	-
Wieczorek	Alfred	Approve, No Comments
Yaghoobi	Hassan	Approve, No Comments
Yanover	Vladimir	Approve, No Comments
Yeh	Choong-Il	-
Yeo	Kunmin	Approve, No Comments
Yoon	Chulsik	Approve, No Comments
Yu	Chang Wahn	Approve, No Comments
Zhu	Peiying	Approve, No Comments

**Satisfied with resolution of all Binding comments.