IEEE 802.16 Letter Ballot #3: Voting Report

Summary

   Condition Met
Votes 85
Approve 76
Disapprove 9
Approval Ratio 89.4% Yes (75% minimum)
Abstain 8
Ballots 93
Eligible Voters 124
Return Ratio 75.0% Yes (50% minimum)
Motion Approved Yes
StatusThe Working Group Chair declares that Confirmation Ballot #3b concluded successfully and that no recirculation is required. As as result, the Chair declares that Working Group Letter Ballot #3 has concluded successfully as of 3 August 2001.

Ballot Details

Last Name First Name Ballot Group Membership Status Vote: LB #3 Vote: Recirc #3a Vote: Confirm #3b Vote: Final
An Song Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Arrakoski Jori Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Arunachalam Arun Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Avivi Eli Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Baugh C. R. Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Belfiore Carlos Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Benyamin-Seeyar Anader Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Bushue Carl Member Abstain for lack of technical expertise

Abstain
Buskila Baruch Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Chang Dean Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Chayat Naftali Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Chayer Rémi Member Approve with non-binding comments

Approve
Condie Mary Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Costa Jose Member Abstain for other reasons

Abstain
Currivan Bruce Member Disapprove with binding comments

Disapprove
Dotan Amos Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Doucet Keith Member Disapprove with binding comments

Disapprove
Durand Roger Member Approve with non-binding comments

Approve
Eidson Brian Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Eklund Carl Member Approve with non-binding comments Approve with non-binding comments
Approve
Falconer David Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Fishel George Member Disapprove with binding comments

Disapprove
Florea Adrian Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Foerster Jeff Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Foster Robert Member Approve with non-binding comments

Approve
Freedman Avi Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Garrison G. Jack Member Disapprove with binding comments Approve with no comments
Approve
Grell Conrad Member Abstain for lack of technical expertise

Abstain
Guillemette Phil Member Disapprove with binding comments Approve with no comments
Approve
Hadad Zion Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Halachmi Baruch Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Hamilton Michael Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Hatim Baya Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Hosur Srinath Member Disapprove with binding comments

Disapprove
Hum Coleman Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Hunter Wayne Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Jacobsen Eric Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Jamali Hamadi Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Jorgensen Jacob Member Disapprove with binding comments Approve with no comments
Approve
Kasslin Mika Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Kiernan Brian Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Kim John Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Kitroser Itzik Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Klein Allan Member Disapprove with binding comments Disapprove with binding comments
Disapprove
Klein Jay Member Approve with non-binding comments Approve with non-binding comments
Approve
Kostas Demos Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Leiba Yigal Member Disapprove with binding comments Approve with no comments Comments only; no vote Approve
Lewis Barry Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Licardie Sergio Member Approve with non-binding comments

Approve
Liebetreu John Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Lindh Lars Member Approve with non-binding comments Approve with non-binding comments
Approve
Lu Willie Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Lucas Fred Member Abstain for lack of technical expertise

Abstain
Marin Scott Member Approve with non-binding comments

Approve
Marks Roger Member Approve with non-binding comments Approve with non-binding comments
Approve
McGregor Andy Member Approve with non-binding comments

Approve
Meyer Ronald Member Approve with non-binding comments

Approve
Middleton Andrew Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Mody Apurva Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Mollenauer Jim Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Myers William Member Disapprove with binding comments Abstain for other reasons
Abstain
Olsen Lou Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Park Yunsang Member Abstain for lack of technical expertise

Abstain
Petry Brian Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Pleasant Wayne Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Ran Moshe Member Approve with no comments
Disapprove with binding comments Disapprove
Reible Stanley Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Rhodes Valentine Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Ribner David Member Disapprove with binding comments

Disapprove
Robinson Gene Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Roehr Walt Member Approve with non-binding comments

Approve
Satapathy Durga Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Sater Glen Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Scaringi Vito Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Schwartz Randall Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Shahar Menashe Member Disapprove with binding comments

Disapprove
Shirali Chet Member Disapprove with binding comments

Disapprove
Stamatelos George Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Stambaugh Karl Member Approve with non-binding comments

Approve
Stanwood Ken Member Approve with non-binding comments Approve with non-binding comments
Approve
Stewart Michael Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Thompson Paul Member Disapprove with binding comments Disapprove with binding comments Approve with no comments Approve
Trinkwon David Member Abstain for lack of technical expertise

Abstain
van Waes Nico Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Varma Subir Member Approve with non-binding comments

Approve
Wang Chao-Chun Member Disapprove with binding comments Approve with no comments
Approve
Ward Bob Member Abstain for lack of technical expertise

Abstain
Whitehead Philip Member Disapprove with binding comments Approve with no comments
Approve
Williams David Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Yanover Vladimir Member Approve with non-binding comments Approve with non-binding comments
Approve
Ye Huanchun Member Disapprove with binding comments Approve with no comments
Approve
Zeng Chaoming Member Approve with no comments

Approve
Zuniga Juan Carlos Member Approve with non-binding comments

Approve
Contreras Luis Nonmember Comments only; no vote

Comments
Escrihuela Francisco Nonmember Comments only; no vote

Comments
Harteneck Moritz Nonmember
Comments only; no vote
Comments
Kalatzis Babis Nonmember
Comments only; no vote
Comments
Karvelas Antonis Nonmember Comments only; no vote Comments only; no vote
Comments
Nunez Gregorio Nonmember Comments only; no vote

Comments
Ponnuswamy Subbu Nonmember Comments only; no vote

Comments
Poza Manuel Nonmember Comments only; no vote

Comments
Kolze Tom Nonmember Comments only; no vote

Comments
Quilez Vicente Nonmember Comments only; no vote

Comments
Schiltz Andy Nonmember Comments only; no vote

Comments
Wang Lei Nonmember
Comments only; no vote
Comments
Wang Stanley Nonmember Comments only; no vote Comments only; no vote
Comments

The following members of the Balloting Group did not submit a ballot:

Aboukarr Bakri
Abu-Dayya Adnan
Akhter Mohammad
Arefi Reza
Baldo Paolo
Baragar Ian
Baseghi Behshad
Bilotta Thomas
Doherty Edward
Evans Allan
Germon Richard
Gupta Rakesh
Hammons, Jr. A. Roger
Kang Inchul
Kwak Byung-Jae
Lazaris-Brunner Ken
McCann Shawn
Monk Anton
Nadiv Ron
Ohmoto Ryutaro
Padan Uzi
Quinn Patrick
Resheff Guy
Sanders Ray
Schafer David
Tateishi Kimiya
Thomas Raymond
Wachira Muya
Winslow Steve
Yee Jung
Zhang Wei
To Letter Ballot #3