IEEE 802.16 Letter Ballot #14: Voting Report

IEEE P802.16e:
"Draft Amendment to IEEE Standard for Local and Metropolitan Area Networks- Part 16: Air Interface for Fixed and Mobile Broadband Wireless Access Systems - Amendment for Physical and Medium Access Control Layers for Combined Fixed and Mobile Operation in Licensed Bands"

Letter Ballot #14 progress, in inverse chronological order:

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Confirmation Ballot #14d: Announcement {CLOSED}

Question: To accept the resolutions of comments from Working Group Recirculation Ballot #14c, as recorded in IEEE 802.16-04/51r3, and to forward, for IEEE 802 LMSC Sponsor Ballot, IEEE P802.16e/D5.
Closing date: 3 October 2004 AOE ("Anywhere on Earth")
Opening date: 18 September 2004
Ballot Submission Form

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Recirculation Ballot #14c: Announcement {CLOSED}

Question: To accept the resolutions of comments from Working Group Recirculation Ballot #14c, as recorded in IEEE 802.16-04/38r4, and to forward, for IEEE 802 LMSC Sponsor Ballot, IEEE P802.16e/D4.
Closing date: 17 August 2004 AOE ("Anywhere on Earth")
Opening date: 2 August 2004
Ballot Submission Form

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Recirculation Ballot #14b: Announcement {CLOSED}

Question: To accept the resolutions of comments from Working Group Recirculation Ballot #14b, as recorded in IEEE 802.16-04/23r3, and to forward, for IEEE 802 LMSC Sponsor Ballot, IEEE P802.16e/D3.
Closing date: 25 June 2004 AOE ("Anywhere on Earth")
Opening date: 7 June 2004
Ballot Submission Form

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Recirculation Ballot #14a: Announcement {CLOSED}

Question: To accept the resolutions of comments from Working Group Letter Ballot #14, as recorded in IEEE 802.16-04/09r2, and to forward, for IEEE 802 LMSC Sponsor Ballot, IEEE P802.16e/D2.
Closing date: 10 May 2004 AOE ("Anywhere on Earth")
Opening date: 5 April 2004
Ballot Submission Form

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #14: Announcement {CLOSED}

Question: To forward IEEE P802.16e/D1 for LMSC Sponsor Ballot.
Closing date: 5 March 2004 AOE ("Anywhere on Earth")
Opening date: 3 February 2004
Ballot Submission Form

Summary Results

Report DateApproveDisVotesApproval
Ratio		Approval Ratio
Condition Met
(>75%)		AbstainBallotsMembersReturn
Ratio		Return Ratio
Condition Met
(>=50%)		Return
Shortfall		Approval
2004/10/04480048100%Yes8566487.5%Yes0Yes; Final
2004/09/2047014897.9%Yes8566487.5%Yes0Yes*
2004/09/1545034893.8%Yes8566487.5%Yes0Yes*
2004/08/2237114877.1%Yes8566487.5%Yes0Yes*
2004/08/02 (14b)36114776.6%Yes8556485.9%Yes0Yes*
2004/05/20 (14a)37104778.7%Yes8556485.9%Yes0Yes*
2004/03/18 (14)3894780.9%Yes7546484.4%Yes0Yes*
*Pending resolution of comments.

Ballot Details

[Updated 04/10/04]
[Note: "-" means "did not return a ballot".]

Name\FamilyName\GivenVote: Letter Ballot #14Vote: Recirc #14aVote: Recirc #14bVote: Recirc #14cVote: Confirm #14dCurrently Disapprove? (with unresolved Binding comments***)
AgrawalAdityaApprove, No Comments

Approve**

Al-DabaghBaraaApprove**DisapproveDisapproveApprove, No Comments

AntonelloGordonApprove, No Comments




ArefiReza-




AviviEliApprove, No Comments




BarberPhillipApprove**
Approve**Approve**

CastelowDavidApprove, CommentsDisapprove
Approve**

ChangDeanApprove, No Comments




ChayatNaftaliApprove, No CommentsDisapproveApprove**


ChayerRémiAbstain for Lack of Technical Expertise




CudakMark
Comments Only



DickStephenApprove, No Comments




EidsonBrianAbstain for Lack of Technical Expertise




EklundCarlDisapproveDisapprove
Approve**

ElineRogerApprove**Approve**DisapproveApprove, No Comments

EngelsMarc-




FreedmanAvrahamApprove**DisapproveApprove, Comments


GarrisonG. Jack-




GoldhammerMariannaApprove, No CommentsApprove**



HadadZionApprove, No CommentsApprove**



HartmanDavid-




JohnsonBrian
Comments Only



JohnstonDavidDisapproveApprove**Approve**


JooPanyuhDisapprove
Approve**Approve, No CommentsApprove, No Comments
KaitzTalApprove, No CommentsApprove**DisapproveApprove**

KelmanOferApprove, Comments




KiernanBrianApprove, No Comments




KitroserItzikApprove, Comments

Approve**

KooChanghoiDisapproveApprove**Approve, CommentsApprove, CommentsApprove, No Comments
LabsJonathanApprove, Comments




LeeChang-JaeComments Only

Comments Only

LeibaYigalApprove, CommentsApprove, CommentsApprove**Approve**

LeimerDonald-




LewisBarry-




LiLingjieApprove, No Comments




LiebetreuJohnDisapprove

Approve, No Comments

LimHyoungsooApprove, No Comments




LindhLarsAbstain for Lack of Technical Expertise




LouHui-Ling-




LycklamaHeinzApprove, No Comments




MandinJeffreyComments OnlyApprove, Comments
Approve, Comments

MarksRogerApprove, Comments




McKownRussellAbstain for Lack of Technical Expertise




MiddletonAndrewAbstain for Lack of Technical Expertise




MuriasRonaldApprove, No CommentsApprove**



NelsonRobertDisapproveDisapproveComments onlyDisapproveApprove, No Comments
PhillipsGregApprove, No Comments




PuthenkulamJoseComments OnlyComments Only



RathKamleshApprove, No Comments
Approve, CommentsComments Only

RobinsonGeneApprove, No Comments




SchwartzRandallApprove**DisapproveDisapproveApprove, No Comments

SegalYossiApprove, No Comments




SeleaRaduApprove, No Comments




SimkinsJamesAbstain for Lack of Technical Expertise




StanwoodKennethDisapproveApprove**



StevensonCarlApprove, No Comments




SuzukiYoshihiro-




TaylorShawnApprove, No Comments




TrinkwonDavidApprove, No CommentsAbstain for Lack of Technical Expertise



UllmannRainerApprove, Comments




van WaesNico-




VerbinEyalApprove, Comments
Approve, Comments


WangArthur-

Approve, No Comments

WangLeiDisapprove

Approve**

WangStanleyApprove, No Comments




WhiteheadPhilipAbstain for Lack of Technical Expertise




YanoverVladimirDisapproveApprove**DisapproveApprove**

YehChoong-ilApprove, No Comments
Approve, CommentsApprove, Comments

YoonChulsikApprove**
DisapproveApprove**Approve, No Comments
**Converted from Disapprove after deadline or based on comment resolution.
***Comment numbers are those in IEEE 802.16-04/38r4 or IEEE 802.16-04/51r3. Comments numbered 1-270 were originally in submitted in Recirc #14a and are recorded in IEEE 802.16-04/23r3. Comments with five-digit numbers were originally submitted in the first Letter Ballot #14 round and are recorded in IEEE 802.16-04/09r2 but without the first two digits of the comment number.