| MR # | Standard | Subclause | Subject | Mar 2005 Status | Jul 2005 Status | Mar 2006 Status | Jul 2006 Status | Nov 2006 Status | Jul 2007 Status | Nov 2007 Status | Jul 2008 Status |
| 0001 | 802.17-2004 | 11.2.5 | The definition of the NOT_USED define for the secMac variable is incorrect. | B | B | ||||||
| 0002 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.5.1 | MS-MS scenario does not retain closed ring topology as described in Figure 11.29. | B | B | ||||||
| 0003 | 802.17-2004 | 7.7.1.6.3 | Ringlet Selection checks for reachability on wrong ringlet. | B | B | ||||||
| 0004 | 802.17-2004 | 10.2.4 | The variable unreservedRate[ri] used in Fairness clause (Pages 273 & 269) should refer to the ringInfo.unreservedRate[ri]. | B | B | ||||||
| 0005 | 802.17-2004 | 7.6.3.10.4 | Data frames with wrong FCS are copied to the client without any verification or validation. | B | B | ||||||
| 0006 | 802.17-2004 | 7.6.3.8.4 | The ps is verified for all frames, but SCFF and MCFF frames do not have this bit. | R | B | ||||||
| 0007 | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.8.4 | In the case of frame.ri != Other (myRi), the value of receivedTtl is not set. | R | B | ||||||
| 0008 | 802.17-2004 | E.1.3 | In the box labeled crcB = HeadCrc16(.c), the c within the parenthesys should be replaced with d. | R | B | ||||||
| 0009 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.5.5 | Four lines are missing at the very end of page 339, so DistantStateMax does not return the correct value. | B | B | ||||||
| 0010 | 802.17-2004 | 10.2.4 | Max() is not defined in Clause 11. | R | B | ||||||
| 0011 | 802.17-2004 | 13.3.1.2 | Not all conditions are covered for declaring the operational state of the RPR interface to be down. | R | B | ||||||
| 0012 | 802.17-2004 | 11.4.2.1 | The values encoded into the station bandwidth ATT should not be weight normalized, and should be converted to timescale used by fairness. | R | B | ||||||
| 0013 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | There are a number of issues with the MIB text not conforming to the main clauses in the standard, having invalid ranges or incorrect cross references. | C | B | ||||||
| 0014 Closed | 802.17-2004 | 6.4.1 | There is no way to configure the MAC to not operate in a strict ordered mode for clients that do no support the strict_order parameter | R | J | ||||||
| 0015 Closed | 802.17-2004 | D.5 | No specified manner to collect summary stats associated with rprSpan*Group and rprClient*Group MIBs. | J | |||||||
| 0016 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | Range of rprIfKeepaliveTimeout object is (2..50) ms. | C | B | ||||||
| 0017 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | Range of rprSpanProtectionHoldOffTimer object is (0..500) ms. | B | B | ||||||
| 0018 Closed | 802.17-2004 | B.2.1.6.1 | 802.3 MAC attributes were mistakenly added to the PacketPHY. | R | W | ||||||
| 0019 | 802.17-2004 | 7.5.7.2.4 | The classC credits are being saved before updating them. | R | B | ||||||
| 0020 | 802.17-2004 | E.2.4 | The frame example shown in Figure E.8 shows the protocolType, and therefore the FCS, starting at the wrong offset into the frame. | R | B | ||||||
| 0021 | 802.17-2004 | 7.8.3.1 | SM22 refers to the wrong state machine. | R | B | ||||||
| 0022 | 802.17-2004 | 12.7.3.4 | SP3 and SP4 refer to the wrong frame type. | R | B | ||||||
| 0023 | 802.17-2004 | 7.5.7.2.4 | Table 7.11, Table 7.12, and Table 7.13 direct taking the Min() of 0 and the credit value after being decremented for one byte. | R | B | ||||||
| 0024 | 802.17-2004 | 7.5.7.2.4 | Table 7.11 and Table 7.12 do not check at entry to the statemachine if the TICK time has expired. | R | B | ||||||
| 0025 | 802.17-2004 | 7.5.7.2.4 | Table 7.11 and Table 7.12 make use of an undefined constant, NORM. | R | T | T | B | ||||
| 0026 | 802.17-2004 | D.5.1.3 | The description of Table D.2 incorrectly limits the applicability to the operational state of down. | B | B | ||||||
| 0027 Closed | 802.17-2004 | 12.4 | The OAM service primitives and the MIB allow specification of a mac_protection parameter. | R | J | ||||||
| 0028 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | The MIB specifies WTR and keepalive as being configured per ring. | R | B | ||||||
| 0029 | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.1.4 | The PerByte statemachine allows neither RATE_BASED nor SHAPER_BASED admission methods to be chosen. | R | B | ||||||
| 0030 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.7.4 | transmitTpFrame is not being set to FALSE. | B | B | ||||||
| 0031 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.8.4 | The row descriptions for Row 3 and Row 4 are switched. | R | B | ||||||
| 0032 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.2.3 | holdoffTimeout and keepaliveTimeout are not shown to be using per-ringlet values. | R | B | ||||||
| 0033 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.3.2 | There is no adminReqProtection defined. | R | B | ||||||
| 0034 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.5.6 | The statemachine rows 10, 11, and 12 do not correspond to the row descriptions. | R | T | B | |||||
| 0035 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.4.4 | The row description for Row 12 is incorrect. | R | B | ||||||
| 0036 Closed | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.1 | The figure shows two links that don't exist. | R | J | ||||||
| 0037 Closed | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.5.6 | This allows an FS to be replaced by an MS. | R | T | J | |||||
| 0038 | 802.17-2004 | 10.2.2 | There is no PICS entry for the "may" in the definition of localWeight, and no corresponding text in the MIB definition. | R | B | ||||||
| 0039 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.6.3 | There is no MIB attribute for stabilityTimeout. | R | B | ||||||
| 0040 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | rprIfCurrentStatus is does not provide status and is missing most of 11.2.9. | R | B | ||||||
| 0041 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | RprTopoImageEntry is missing an attribute corresponding to spanEdge[ri]. | R | B | ||||||
| 0042 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | rprTopoImageWestProtectionStatus and rprTopoImageEastProtectionStatus are not statuses and are not bit fields. | R | B | ||||||
| 0043 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | rprTopoImageStatus fields receivedBadFcs and receivedMultichokeFairness are not events indicating such things have been received. | R | B | ||||||
| 0044 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.13.3 | Extraneous '{' and '}'s. | R | B | ||||||
| 0045 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.4.4 | The protMisconfigDefect is not cleared even after the configuration mismatch has been corrected. | B | B | ||||||
| 0046 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.5.5 | DistantStateMax() does not return the correct value of awayState for cases in which a station has an edge, but the edge is not caused by the station on the far-end of the span. | T | T | I | B | ||||
| 0047 Closed | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.3.4 | A station may become the head of a congestion domain based solely on the rate of transiting non-reserved traffic. | T | T | J | |||||
| 0048 | 802.17-2004 | 7.2.2 | The definition of classCAccessDelayTimer suggests that the timer specifies the longest waiting time of any traffic waiting for transmission. | T | T | B | |||||
| 0049 Closed | 802.17-2004 | 7.5.6.4 | Table 7.10 Row 4 does not cover the case in which there are multiple frames waiting, and only some were sent. | T | T | J | |||||
| 0050 | 802.17-2004 | 7.5.7.4.4 | The value of creditS is always equal to zero. | R | B | ||||||
| 0051 | 802.17-2004 | 12.1.4 | Echo frames are requested by the client, and not the management system. | R | B | ||||||
| 0052 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | rprSpanStatsInOamEchoFrames and rprSpanStatsOutOamEchoFrames each mistakenly combined two counters from the standard. | R | B | ||||||
| 0053 Closed | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | The control frames counters in RprSpanCountersStatsEntry are in the wrong location. | R | J | ||||||
| 0054 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.5.5 | DistantStateMax() does not correctly handle the 2-station case. | R | T | B | |||||
| 0055 Closed | 802.17-2004 | 7.6.3.8.4 | Multicast or broadcast control frames can increment the ttlExpiredFrames counter. | R | T | J | |||||
| 0056 | 802.17-2004 | 7.6.2 | The term "flow" is used without a definition. | - | R | B | |||||
| 0057 | 802.17-2004 | 10.5 | The heading for the third row of Table 10.16 is incorrect. | - | R | B | |||||
| 0058 | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.1.4 | Incorrect row description for Row 10.5-5. | - | R | B | |||||
| 0059 | 802.17-2004 | 7.7.1.2.5 | For a center-wrapping ring with bidirectional flooding, wouldn't that still be replicated with the we==1? | - | R | B | |||||
| 0060 Closed | 802.17-2004 | 7.7.1.6.4 | Incorrect ringlet selection for a bidirectional flooded frame on a center-wrapped station. | - | R | T | J | ||||
| 0061 Closed | 802.17-2004 | 7.7.1.6.4 | Problems with topo frames and fairness frames for a center-wrapped station. | - | R | T | J | ||||
| 0062 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | Extra space in "size Stq". | - | R | B | |||||
| 0063 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | The rprOamRequestCount is not cross-referenced to an RPR variable. | - | R | B | |||||
| 0064 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | The rprOamTimeout is not cross-referenced to an RPR variable. | - | R | B | |||||
| 0065 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | The rprOamControl is not cross-referenced to an RPR variable. | - | R | B | |||||
| 0066 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | The rprOamResponseCount is not cross-referenced to an RPR variable. | - | R | B | |||||
| 0067 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | The rprOamAvResponseTime is not cross-referenced to an RPR variable. | - | R | B | |||||
| 0068 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | The rprOamResponseStatus is not cross-referenced to an RPR variable. | - | R | B | |||||
| 0069 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | Wrong name: "toClientUcastClassBCirAFrames". | - | R | B | |||||
| 0070 Closed | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | There is an entry for client-in broadcast counts, but not multicast. | - | R | J | |||||
| 0071 Closed | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | There is an entry for client-out broadcast counts, but not multicast. | - | R | J | |||||
| 0072 | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.4.4 | rampUpCoef does not belong in the condition of Row 5. | - | R | T | B | ||||
| 0073 | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.4.4 | allowedRate is calculated twice in Row 5 and Row 16. The later calculation overrides the early one. | - | R | B | |||||
| 0074 | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.5.4 | Incorrect comparison between fairRate and receivedRate. | - | R | B | |||||
| 0075 | 802.17-2004 | 7.7.10.4 | Wrong table name. | - | R | B | |||||
| 0076 | 802.17-2004 | 7.7.1.6.4 | A frame with a multicast DA can be sent on the ring with frame.fi = FI_NONE. | - | R | B | |||||
| 0077 Closed | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.8.4 | If there's a fiber loopback, ReceiveTpFrame can not report this specific error, just a large scope error of miscabling. | - | - | J | |||||
| 0078 | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.2.3 | ResetStqWatermarks() resets stqHighWatermark to stqSize. | - | - | B | |||||
| 0079 | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.2.4 | Wrong routine name, InitLowPassFilteredRates(), in Table 10.6. | - | - | B | |||||
| 0080 | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.10.5 | frtt is computed before LrttToTail is computed. | - | - | B | |||||
| 0081 | 802.17-2004 | 6.3.1 | The MAC service interface provides the number of hops to the congestion point, not the nearest congested station. | - | - | B | |||||
| 0082 Closed | 802.17-2004 | 12.3.1 | Add a timestamp mechanism for oam echo request/response frame. | - | - | J | |||||
| 0083 Closed | 802.17-2004 | F | Problems of cross-ring RPR reliability and rapid switchover. | - | - | J | |||||
| 0084 | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.9.4 | frame.ri of an FDD frame is wrongly assigned the value of receivedRi. | - | - | B | |||||
| 0085 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | The attributes of RprSpanErrorCountersCurrentEntry do not state where they get their values. | - | - | T | B | ||||
| 0086 | 802.17-2004 | 12.6.1.2 | scffErrors is insufficiently defined. | - | - | T | B | ||||
| 0087 Closed | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.8.4 | Line 9 condition "myWrappingMethod ==CENTER_WRAP" is not relevant when "myEdgeState==FROM_EDGE". | - | - | T | J | ||||
| 0088 | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.10.6 | Wrong wrapPoint values in FrttComputation. | - | - | R | T | B | |||
| 0089 | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.10.5 | The function AgeFdd (fdd, newFdd) does not declare 'lastReceivedFdd' as a variable or as a function parameter. | - | - | R | B | ||||
| 0090 | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.10.6 | Wrong value used for hop count to tailIndex. | - | - | R | T | B | |||
| 0091 | 802.17-2004 | 7.6.3.6.4 | If a Multichoke fairness frame (MCFF) is caught on the wrong ringlet, it will stay forever. | - | - | R | B | ||||
| 0092 | 802.17-2004 | 7.6.3.9.4 | The description of Row 7.23-4 is not consistent with the action in the table, and it is wrong. | - | - | R | B | ||||
| 0093 | 802.17-2004 | 7.7.2 | The figure seems to imply that there is a failure in the ring, but it describes the normal operating case. | - | - | R | B | ||||
| 0094 | 802.17-2004 | 7.6.3.8.4 | Table row 7.22-7 has the wrong parameter name in the condition column. | - | - | R | B | ||||
| 0095 | 802.17-2004 | 7.6.3.9.4 | Table row 7.23-4 has the wrong parameter name in the condition column. | - | - | R | B | ||||
| 0096 | 802.17-2004 | 7.6.3.5.4 | Table row 7.19-6 has the wrong function name in the condition column. | - | - | R | B | ||||
| 0097 | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.2.3 | stqSize is not a defined variable. | - | - | R | B | ||||
| 0098 | 802.17-2004 | 10.2.4 | myWrappingMethod is not a defined variable. | - | - | R | B | ||||
| 0099 | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.5.4 | Wrong description for table row 10.10-4. | - | - | R | B | ||||
| 0100 | 802.17-2004 | 12.4.1 | In the ringlet_id definition, the reference table is wrong. | - | - | R | B | ||||
| 0101 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | The definition of rprIfWrapConfig incorrectly uses "Wrap preferred". | - | - | R | B | ||||
| 0102 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | In the definition of rprIfJumboFramePreferred, rprIfMacCapability should be replaced with rprIfRingOperModes. | - | - | R | B | ||||
| 0103 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.4.4 | Table-Row 11.14-17 does not save the checksum value. | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0104 | 802.17-2004 | 3.2.78 | There is no such literal: "AGECOEF". | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0105 | 802.17-2004 | 7.6.3.8.2 | ttlExpiredFrames is not defined in 7.2.2. | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0106 | 802.17-2004 | 7.7.7.2.4 | There is no such routine: "PHY_READY.inidication()". | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0107 | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.4.4 | Table-Row 10.9 condition uses an undefined routine: "IsCongested()". | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0108 | 802.17-2004 | 11.4.3.3 | Reference is given to the wrong subclause, and no reference is given to myTopoInfo.conservativeMode. | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0109 | 802.17-2004 | 11.4.3.4 | Reference is given to the wrong subclause, and no reference is given to myTopoInfo.multichokeUser. | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0110 | 802.17-2004 | 11.4.3.4 | The text wrongly implies separate actions for multichoke behavior for each ringlet. | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0111 | 802.17-2004 | 11.4.3.4 | The last paragraph on page 311 appears to belong to 11.4.3.4. | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0112 | 802.17-2004 | 11.7.3.4 | Checking the Yes box of PP6 does not indicate that nonrevertive operation "may be" supported. | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0113 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | The reference for rprFairnessReservedRate refers to 11.2.4. | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0114 | 802.17-2004 | 10.4.10.6 | tailSa, tailRi, and tailIndex are not defined. | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0115 | 802.17-2004 | 7.6.3.10.2 | The badRxFcsFrames statistics counter is not reflected in any MIB item. | - | - | - | R | T | B | ||
| 0116 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.14.3 | There is no definition of variable advertisementInterval used in context of function LrttResponseHandle(). | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0117 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.7.4 | TP frames should be broadcasted in both ringlets. | - | - | - | R | T | B | ||
| 0118 | 802.17-2004 | 0 | Inconsistent notation "frame.checksumValid" in Table 11.20 rows 6 and 9. | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0119 | 802.17-2004 | 7.7.4 | Final hec field value may be incorrect for frame header. | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0120 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.3.4 | "EntryInQueue(Q_RX_TP_PARSE) != NULL" (Table 11.13, Row 3) is a tautology. | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0121 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.2 | There is no holdoffStartTime[ri] variable definition. | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0122 | 802.17-2004 | 7.6.3.5.4 | keepaliveTime is an integer variable in some places, but it is defined as an array. | - | - | - | R | B | |||
| 0123 | 802.17-2004 | 7.2.1 | There is no definition of queue Q_TX_ROUTE. | - | - | - | R | R | B | ||
| 0124 | 802.17-2004 | J.3 | There are missing exclamation marks in Table J.1. | - | - | - | R | R | B | ||
| 0125 | 802.17-2004 | 7.6.3.8.4 | ReceiveStrip state machine is allowed to update keepalive variable when station has span failure. | - | - | - | R | R | T | B | |
| 0126 | 802.17-2004 | 1.6.6.5 | If topoEntryInvalidDefect is set in TopologyValidation state machine, it isn`t cleared when topology is valid. | - | - | - | R | R | B | ||
| 0127 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.8.4 | Inconsistent notation "frame.seq" in ReceiveTpFrame state machine specification. | - | - | - | R | R | B | ||
| 0128 | 802.17-2004 | 0 | Wrong notation of condition currentTime-wtr[ri].time >= wtr.timeout[ri]. | - | - | - | R | R | B | ||
| 0129 | 802.17-2004 | 11.6.6.4 | Definition of routine SetSourceCheck() contains wrong condition. | - | - | - | R | R | B | ||
| 0130 | 802.17-2004 | D.6 | Incorrect description in the rprIfIdleThreshold MIB item. | - | - | - | R | R | B | ||
| 0131 | 802.17-2004 | 11.2.3 | txSlowTimeout variable specified a default of 100msec | - | - | - | R | R | T | B | |
| 0132 | 802.17-2004 | 11.5.4 | Figure 11.27f lists the wrong topoType. | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | B |
| 0133 | 802.17-2004 | 7.7.1.6.4 | Control frame fields are being treated as data frames. | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | B |
| 0134 | 802.17-2004 | 7.7.1.6.4 | FDD frames are not being allowed to wrap. | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | B |