[802.3_ISAAC] Aw: [802.3_ISAAC] Invitation to the 802.3dm comparison study

[Mathias Kleinwaechter <0000457756a3b153-dmarc-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Dear 802.3dm Task Force members,

 

I support the approach to create a comparison and summary presentation as a technical qualified overview.

As I am not an expert in PHY design with its complexity, it is sometimes hard for me to follow the presentations and especially evaluate the relevance and importance of certain aspects in relation to the whole technical solution.

In such uncertain situations, it is a proven engineering approach for me to create an overview as support tool for further actions and decisions. I actually considered creating an overwiew on my own based on all presentations. But this would surely be incomplete and definitly not qualified.

Thus, working together on a systematic comparison that identifies all aspects, relevance, commonalities and discussion points, etc is a great idea.

I encourage especially the technical experts to contribute to this process.

 

Thank you and kind regards

Mathias

 

 

 

Gesendet: Donnerstag, 22. Mai 2025 um 16:49

Von: "Veloso Cauce Gumersindo, EE-352" <000045712ce4d5b2-dmarc-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>

An: STDS-802-3-ISAAC@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Betreff: [802.3_ISAAC] Invitation to the 802.3dm comparison study

Dear 802.3dm participants,

 

As announced on both the May 1^st and May 16^th 802.3dm interim meetings, here are the details for the next steps on our joint comparison study.

 

1. In the first step, we would like to agree on a list of criteria to address before discussing the fulfillment of any criteria. In the attachment you find a PROPOSAL for the comparison criteria and their metrics. Please take careful look at them and evaluate if additional criteria or metrics are needed.
2. Send us your updated list (if any) until May 26^th EOB. We know this is short notice, however, this only identifies the criteria deemed important and not their fulfillment – for which we will then dedicate more time.
3. We start on May 28^th 15:00 CET with a Kick-Off meeting.
1. Introduce a proposal for the structure for the final document which shall result from our efforts.
2. Check on the collected criteria and discuss the collected input.
3. Next steps on the proposed items to elaborate fulfillment details.
4. Starting on June 4^th we would then initiate a weekly series till July 23^rd. Each week we discuss criteria fulfillment based on the incoming proposals shared with the group prior to the meetings.
5. Step by step completion/creation of the comparison document.

 

If you would like to participate in this meeting, please reply to either me or Kirsten (Kirsten.matheus@xxxxxx) and you will receive a dedicated meeting invite (Teams-Link) or just join with the following link at the dedicated time:

 

Jetzt an der Besprechung teilnehmen

Besprechungs-ID: 337 645 339 451 3

Kennung: 9XF9JW7a

 

You are welcome to send your input on the comparison items also if you are not able to join the meeting.

 

We are looking forward to your responses.

 

Thank you and best regards.

 

Gumersindo Veloso

 

P.s: For those not present at the last meetings, this is the motivation:

 

• Currently, two technical proposals are competing within IEEE 802.3dm.
• This documents aims to compare the two proposals and their rationales in order to provide an overview on the key properties and the different opinions on them.
• It may serve as a “technically qualified overview at a glance” reference for individuals wanting to understand and form their own opinion.
• The intention with this comparison document is
• to clarify where there are agreements and disagreements.
• to make the disagreements understandable.
• This document
• does not present a unified opinion.
• does not favor one proposal over the other.
• The authors prepare this document with the best intention to present an unbiased reference.

 

 

--
BMW Group
Gumersindo Veloso Cauce
EE-352

Systemfunktionen, Halbleiter, Vernetzungstechnologien
Max-Diamandstr. 5
80937 München

 

Postanschrift:

80788 München

Tel: +49-89-382-36389
Mobile: +49-151-601-36389
Mail: gumersindo.veloso@xxxxxx
Web: http://www.bmwgroup.com/

 

----------------------------------------------------------------
Bayerische Motoren Werke Aktiengesellschaft
Vorstand/Board of Management: Oliver Zipse (Vorsitzender/Chairman),
Jochen Goller, Ilka Horstmeier, Walter Mertl, Milan Nedeljković, Joachim Post, Frank Weber
Vorsitzender des Aufsichtsrats/Chairman of the Supervisory Board: Norbert Reithofer
Sitz und Registergericht/Domicile and Court of Registry: München HRB 42243
----------------------------------------------------------------

 

 

---

To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-3-ISAAC list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-3-ISAAC&A=1

---

To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-3-ISAAC list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-3-ISAAC&A=1