Attendees:
Dong
Wei
Ed
Eckert
Sam
Heidari
Vladimir
Oksman
Arthur
Marris
Massimo
Sorbara
Hugh
Barrass
Miguel
Peeters
Bernard
Debbasch
Sabina
Fanfoni
Subject: Table 62B-1
10PASS-TS Test Cases
The group agreed to
refer to test cases by the "old" (D2.0) test numbers for the
duration of the call.
It was noted that the
test cases fall into three groups:
Group 1: 1-9 basic tests
(10/10 Mbps)
Group 2: 10-20
notching off
Group 3: 21-31
notching on
In general, Groups 2 and
3 are identical conditions, except for the presence of
notching.
It was pointed out that
some of the changes made in Ancona
to Group 2 were not made to Group 3. Since these changes
involved reduction in reach, this makes the table inconsistent, as
the presence of notching will not increase channel
capacity.
Accordingly, the
attendees agreed that it would be desirable to change #29 to 750m, #
25 to 650m and #23 from Self noise to AWGN. There was not
unanimous opinion to delete #22, as was done with #11 in
Ancona.
However, there was
general agreement that we would focus on Groups 1 & 3, and any
changes made to Group 3 would be reflected in Group
2.
Sabina stated we should
use ETSI A/F noise models when we use ETSI
profiles
Vladimir
took the assignment to supply more detailed specification for UPBO,
especially for Self and AWGN noise models, prior to the next
conference call.
One of the unsatisfied
TR's asks that simulation results or another method be presented in
order to justify the numbers in the table. In order to proceed
with simulations, the assumptions must be agreed
to.
Miguel suggested we
start with Annex F of the ETSI standard [ETSI TS 101 270-1 V1.3.1
(2003-07)]. He took the assignment to come up with a proposal
for assumptions for the group to use, based upon the ETSI document,
prior to the next conference call.
Next conference call
will be Thursday, 23-October, at 6
p.m. Geneva
time (9
a.m. PDT).