Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

Re: [802.3_OMEGA] Proposal to move forward with #i-107 and #i-108 comment resolution

Colleagues,

I have received valuable comments on the proposed response and motion wording, in addition to Ramana's proposal to change the Straw Poll.

Regarding the latter, I prefer to stick to the comment resolution with a Straw Poll linked to the comments we are trying to resolve. Fortunately, we have previously agreed upon text within the TF on wavelength, and having an Straw Poll with two options to fill a gap that does not exist in the draft simply does not reflects the current situation.

In my opinion our focus should be to complete the comment resolution.

My updated proposal is the following (modifications explained in italic):

  1. Add to Proposed Response of comments #i-107 and #i-108 the following sentence, acknowledging the discussions we had last week (reference to "cost" has been removed):
  2. Conduct an Straw Poll on the two modified Proposed Responses to measure the consensus around them with the following text (Added "modified" in the straw poll wording):
            Straw Poll #TBD
            Approve the modified proposed response to comments #i-107 and #i-108 as drafted by the editor.
            (Technical >= 75%)
            Yes
            No
            Abstain
  3. If the straw poll is favorable, I have the intention to move the same motion I withdrew last week, with the following text: (Mr. Grow has indicated that the motion and vote should be added to the comment response)

            Motion #TBD
            Move to approve the modified proposed response to comments #i-107 and #i-108 as drafted by the editor.
            (Technical >= 75%)

                Yes
                No
                Abstain
  4. Similarly, any motions from anyone else to adopt a different response would be included in the comment responses.
  5. As has been done for years in 802.3 comment resolution when no consensus on the Proposed Responses is reached, add to bot Proposed Responses the following sentence:

Thanks!

Kind Regards,

Luisma

El 17/10/2022 a las 18:31, Luis Manuel Torres escribió:

Colleagues,

Last week we were discussing in depth to change the current 802.3cz/D3.01 draft.Arguments on the technical and on the cost impact of the system and testing tools were given, and we had very interesting presentations by Ramana and Rubén (See https://www.ieee802.org/3/cz/public/oct_2022/murty_3cz_01_1022.pdf and https://www.ieee802.org/3/cz/public/oct_2022/perezaranda_3cz_02_1022_vcsel_rel.pdf).

In my opinion, tomorrow we should measure whether there is consensus to change the current draft text, and also resolve the rest of the comments that remain to be resolved.

So, my proposal is the following:

  1. Add to Proposed Response of comments #i-107 and #i-108 the following sentence, acknowledging the discussions we had last week:
  1. Conduct an Straw Poll on the two modified Proposed Responses to measure the consensus around them with the following text:
    1. Straw Poll #TBD
      Approve the proposed response to comments #i-107 and #i-108 as drafted by the editor.
      (Technical >= 75%)
      Yes
      No
      Abstain

  2.  In case that no consensus on the Proposed Responses is reached, add to both Proposed Responses the following sentence:
  3. I intend to move the same motion that I tabled last week, with the following text:
Motion #TBD
Move to approve the proposed response to comments #i-107 and #i-108 as drafted by the editor.
(Technical >= 75%)
Yes
No
Abstain

I think this is the best way to move forward, try to complete the remaining comments, and generate the next version of the draft for comment at our Bangkok meeting.

Kind Regards,

Luisma Torres

IEEE 802.3cz Chief Editor


--
Luisma Torres
Principal Engineer at KDPOF
 
Knowledge Development for POF, S.L.
A: Ronda de Poniente 14 2º CD, 28760, Tres Cantos (Madrid), Spain
P: + 34 91 804 33 87 Ext:110
M: +34 681 29 11 53
E: luismanuel.torres@xxxxxxxxx
W: https://www.kdpof.com
 

 

To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-3-OMEGA list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-3-OMEGA&A=1