Letter Ballot #30: Status Report
Note: At the Closing Plenary of IEEE 802.16 Session #65, on 14 January 2010, the WG approved a motion "That the WG terminate LB #30 and initiate a new WG LB #31 of new WG draft P802.16m/D4 based on the comment resolutions contained in 802.16-10/0001r2."IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot Recirc #30b: Announcement
IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot Recirc #30a: Announcement
IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #30: Announcement
| Report Date | Approve | Dis | Sum | Approval Ratio |
Approval Ratio Condition Met (>75%) |
Abstain | Ballots | Members | Return Ratio |
Return Ratio Condition Met (>=50%) |
Return Shortfall |
Approval Conditions met+ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2010/01/04 | 196 | 95 | 291 | .67 | No | 2 | 293 | 437 | .67 | Yes | 0 | No |
[ Updated
10/01/04, 04:43 PM
]
Note: This report is infrequently updated while the ballot is open. However, you may check a real-time report of ballot submittals.
| Name\Family | Name\Given | Letter Ballot #30 |
|---|---|---|
| Abdallah | Mohamed | - |
| Abrishami | Ray | Disapprove (b) |
| Agarwal | Rajni | Disapprove (b) |
| Agiwal | Anil | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Ahmadi | Sassan | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Ahn | JunBae | - |
| Aloush | Avner | - |
| Ambroise | Xavier | Approve, No Comments |
| Andelman | Dov | Approve, Comments |
| Annavajjala | Ramesh | - |
| Aoki | Tsuguhide | - |
| Arefi | Reza | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Bacioccola | Andrea | - |
| Bajaj | Rashmi | - |
| Barber | Phillip | Disapprove |
| Bims | Harry | - |
| Boariu | Adrian | - |
| Bourlas | Yair | - |
| Boyer | Adrian | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Cai | Sean | Disapprove |
| Cain | Peter | - |
| Chae | Suchang | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Chang | Sung-Cheol | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Chang | Xin | - |
| Chang | YoungBin | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Chang | Yu-Hao | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Chayat | Naftali | Disapprove |
| Chen | Cheng-Ming | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Chen | Clark | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Chen | Mei-Dai | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Chen | Ren-Jr | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Chen | Wei-Peng | Approve, No Comments |
| Chen | Wen Kai | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Chen | Whai-En | Disapprove (b) |
| Chen | Yih-Shen | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Chen | Yung-Han | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Chen | Yuqin | Disapprove (b) |
| Cheng | Paul | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Cheng | Ray-Guang | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Chindapol | Aik | Approve, No Comments |
| Chion | Hua (Mary) | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Chiu | Chun-Yuan | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Cho | HanGyu | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Cho | Jaehee | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Cho | Jaeweon | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Cho | Youngbo | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Choi | Hokyu | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Choi | Hyoung-Jin | - |
| Choi | Jinsoo | Disapprove (b) |
| Choi | Joonyoung | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Choi | Yang-Seok | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Chou | Chao-Chin | Disapprove (b) |
| Chou | Chie Ming | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Chou | Ching-Chun | Disapprove (a) |
| Chou | Joey | Disapprove |
| Chow | Jerry | Disapprove |
| Chuang | Ming-Hsueh | Disapprove (b) |
| Chun | Jin Young | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Chun | Joon Hwa | - |
| Clerckx | Bruno | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Colban | Erik | - |
| Costa | José | Disapprove |
| Crowley | Steven | Approve, No Comments |
| Cudak | Mark | Disapprove |
| Davydov | Alexey | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Dayal | Pranav | - |
| Dhaliwal | Upkar | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Digham | Fadel | - |
| Doostnejad | Roya | - |
| Du | Ying | - |
| Du | Yinggang | - |
| Eastwood | Lester | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Eklund | Carl | Disapprove |
| Erlihson | Michael | Approve, No Comments |
| Ernström | Per | - |
| Etemad | Kamran | - |
| Eun | Yu-Chang | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Ezri | Doron | - |
| Fahldieck | Torsten | - |
| Fan | Linghang | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Fang | Huiying | Disapprove (b) |
| Fang | Yu-Chuan | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Feder | Peretz | - |
| Feng | Chengyan | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Fong | Mo-Han | Disapprove |
| Freedman | Avraham | Disapprove (a) |
| Fu | I-Kang | Disapprove (b) |
| Fwu | Jong-Kae (JK) | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Gal | Dan | Disapprove |
| Geles | Mark | - |
| Ghasemi | Amir | - |
| Glassford | Rob | - |
| Goh | Wee Peng | - |
| Goldhamer | Mariana | Disapprove |
| Gosteau | Jeremy | - |
| Griot | Miguel | - |
| Guan | Yanfeng | Disapprove (b) |
| Gundlach | Michael | Disapprove (a) |
| Hadad | Zion | Disapprove (b) |
| Hahn | GeneBeck | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Hamiti | Shkumbin | - |
| Han | Seung Hee | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Hanaoka | Seishi | - |
| Harel | Tom | Disapprove (a) |
| Hart | Mike | - |
| Hayase | Shigenori | - |
| Himayat | Nageen | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Ho | Chieh Yuan | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Ho | Chung-Lien | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Ho | Minnie | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Hsiao | Chang-Lung | Approve, No Comments |
| Hsiao | Ying-Chuan | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Hsieh | Ching-Tarng | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Hsieh | Yu-Tao | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Hsu | Chun-Yen | Disapprove (b) |
| Hsu | Chung-Hsien | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Hsu | Hsien-Tsung | - |
| Hsu | Jen-Yuan | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Hsuan | Yi | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Hu | Teck | - |
| Huang | Cancan | - |
| Huang | Din Hwa | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Huang | Lei | Disapprove (b) |
| Hui | Jie | Approve, Comments |
| Hui | Junhong | - |
| Humbert | John | - |
| Hur | Yerang | - |
| Ihm | Bin-Chul | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Ikeda | Tetsu | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Imata | Satoshi | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Iyengar | Rajagopal | - |
| Jan | Yih Guang | Disapprove (b) |
| Jang | Jaehyuk | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Jee | Junghoon | - |
| Jeon | Hyung Joon | - |
| Ji | Baowei | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Jin | Lei | Disapprove (b) |
| Jin | Sunggeun | Approve, No Comments |
| Johnsson | Kerstin | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Johnston | David | - |
| Josiam | Kaushik | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Juang | Rong-Terng | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Jung | Bang Chul | - |
| Jung | Inuk | Disapprove (b) |
| Jung | Soojung | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Kang | Heewon | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Kang | Hyunjeong | Disapprove (b) |
| Kang | Jianfeng | - |
| Kang | Minsuk | - |
| Kang | Seunghyun | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Kao | Chien-Yu | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Kato | Tsuguo | Approve, No Comments |
| Khan | Farooq Ullah | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Khojastepour | Mohammad | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Khoryaev | Alexey | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Kiernan | Brian | Approve, No Comments |
| Kim | Bong Ho | - |
| Kim | Dongcheol | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Kim | Eunkyung | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Kim | Jeong Gon | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Kim | Jihyung | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Kim | Juhee | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Kim | Jung-Im | - |
| Kim | Namgi | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Kim | Ronny (Yong-Ho) | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Kim | Sang Gook | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Kim | Sangheon | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Kim | Sungkyung | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Kim | Taeyoung | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Kim | Won Ik | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Kim | Young Kyun | - |
| Kim | Young-Il | - |
| Kishigami | Takaaki | Disapprove |
| Kitroser | Itzik | - |
| Klutto Milleth | J. | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Koc | Ali | Approve, No Comments |
| Kone | Mamadou | - |
| Koo | Changhoi | - |
| Korakis | Thanasis | - |
| Korkmaz | Gokhan | Disapprove |
| Kuchi | Kiran Kumar | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Kuo | Ping-Heng | Disapprove (b) |
| Kuze | Toshiyuki | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Kwak | Byung-Jae | - |
| Kwak | Jin-Sam | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Kwon | Dong Seung | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Kwon | Young Hoon | Disapprove (b) |
| Kwon | Young-Hyoun | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Labonte | Sylvain | - |
| Labs | Jonathan | Disapprove (b) |
| Lee | Hyun | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Lee | HyunWoo | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Lee | Jeong Julie | - |
| Lee | Jin | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Lee | Ju Seung | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Lee | Jungwon | - |
| Lee | Ki-Dong | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Lee | Kyounghwan | - |
| Lee | Mi Hyun | Disapprove (b) |
| Lee | Sook-Jin | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Lee | Sukwoo | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Lee | Sungjin | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Lee | Wookbong | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Lee | Yang-Han | Disapprove (b) |
| Lee | Youn-Tai | Disapprove (a) |
| Lee | Yung-Ting | - |
| Li | Guangjie | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Li | Richard | Approve, No Comments |
| Li | Shaohua | - |
| Li | Ying | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Li | Zexian | Disapprove (b) |
| Liao | Pei-Kai | Disapprove (b) |
| Liao | Wei-Shun | - |
| Lim | Junsung | - |
| Lim | Kwangjae | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Lin | Chih-Yuan | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Lin | Hsin-Piao | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Lin | Kuhn-Chang | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Lin | Kun-Yi | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Lin | Yi-Ting | Disapprove (b) |
| Liu | Chongli | Disapprove (b) |
| Liu | Hang | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Liu | Lina | Disapprove (b) |
| Liu | Yang | Disapprove (b) |
| Livschitz | Michael | - |
| Loa | Kanchei | Disapprove (b) |
| Lu | Jianmin | Disapprove (b) |
| Lu | Zhaohua | Disapprove (b) |
| Lv | Kaiying | Disapprove (b) |
| Lynch | Michael | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Madihian | Mohammad | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Maeder | Andreas | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Maez | David | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Maggi | Giovanni | - |
| Maheshwari | Shashikant | - |
| Maiberger | Roy | - |
| Maltsev | Alexander | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Mao | Ronald | Disapprove |
| Marks | Roger | Disapprove (b) |
| Marque-Pucheu | Gerard | Approve, No Comments |
| Maskatia | Arif | - |
| Masters | Jeffery | - |
| Matsumoto | Wataru | - |
| Mazzarese | David | Approve, Comments (b) |
| McBeath | Sean | Disapprove |
| McGinniss | David | - |
| Meddour | Djamal-Eddine | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Migaldi | Scott | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Mlinarsky | Fanny | - |
| Mohanty | Shantidev | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Molisch | Andreas | - |
| Mondal | Bishwarup | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Monogioudis | Pantelis | - |
| Moon | Sungho | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Muck | Markus | Disapprove (b) |
| Murias | Ronald | Disapprove (b) |
| Naguib | Ayman | - |
| Nakamura | Michiharu | Disapprove |
| Nakatsugawa | Keiichi | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Nguyen | An | - |
| Niu | Huaning | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Nohara | Mitsuo | Approve, No Comments |
| Novak | Robert | - |
| Oh | Changyoon | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Oh | Min-Seok | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Okuda | Masato | Disapprove |
| Olfat | Masoud | - |
| Olszewski | Kim | - |
| Ono | Ryoji | - |
| Orlik | Philip | - |
| Ostling | Per-Erik | - |
| Otterbach | Juergen | - |
| Papathanassiou | Apostolos | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Park | Giwon | Disapprove (b) |
| Park | Hyungho | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Park | Jeongho | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Park | Michael | - |
| Park | Sung-Eun | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Park | Youn Ok | - |
| Patel | Vijay | - |
| Peng | Yan | Disapprove (b) |
| Pi | Zhouyue | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Pillai | Vinod Ramaswamy | - |
| Pirhonen | Riku | - |
| Porat | Ron | - |
| Power | Kevin | Disapprove (a) |
| Probasco | Scott | Disapprove (b) |
| Puthenkulam | Jose | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Qi | Xin | - |
| Qian | Nanjian (Jeff) | - |
| Qu | Hongyun | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Rabineau | Rodrigue | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Ramakrishna | Sudhir | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Reddy | Ranga K | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Redlich | Oded | - |
| Ren | Fang-Ching | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Riegel | Maximilian | Disapprove |
| Roh | Kwanhee | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Roh | Wonil | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Rong | Zhigang | Disapprove (b) |
| Ruck | Herbert | Disapprove (b) |
| Ryu | Byung-Han | - |
| Ryu | Kiseon | Disapprove (b) |
| Saifullah | Yousuf | - |
| Sambasivan | Sam | - |
| Sarperi | Luciano | Disapprove (b) |
| Sayeedi | Shahab | Disapprove (a) |
| Schaepperle | Joerg | Disapprove |
| Schneider | Thomas | - |
| Schumacher | Joseph | Disapprove (b) |
| Seagren | Chris | Abstain for Lack of Time (a) |
| Seol | Ji-Yun | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Shalash | Ahmed | Abstain for Lack of Time (a) |
| Shang | Zheng | - |
| Shekalim | Peretz | Disapprove (b) |
| Shen | Gang | - |
| Sherman | Matthew | - |
| Shilo | Shimi | - |
| Shim | Jaejeong (Brian) | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Shin | Wooram | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Shono | Takashi | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Shyy | D. J. | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Si | Hongjie | - |
| Sivanesan | Kathiravetpillai | - |
| Sjoberg | Sten | Approve, No Comments |
| So | Tricci | Disapprove |
| Son | Jung Je | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Son | Yeongmoon | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Song | Ting-Chen (Tom) | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Song | Young Seog | - |
| Soong | Anthony | Disapprove (b) |
| Srinivasan | Roshni | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Stanwood | Kenneth | Approve, No Comments |
| Su | Hsuan-Jung | - |
| Su | Huan-Yu | - |
| Su | Xin | - |
| Sun | Bo | Disapprove (b) |
| Sun | Hongmei | - |
| Sun | Li-Hsiang | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Sun | Yakun | - |
| Sun | Yong | - |
| Sung | Doo-hyun | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Sydir | Jaroslaw J | Approve, Comments |
| Sydor | John | - |
| Takai | Mineo | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Talukdar | Anup | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Tang | Yang | Disapprove (b) |
| Tao | Jeffrey | - |
| Tao | Ming-Hung | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Taori | Rakesh | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Taylor | Shawn | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Thakare | Kiran | - |
| Thome | Timothy | - |
| Ting | Pangan | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Tonnerre | Arnaud | Approve, No Comments |
| Trigui | Hafedh | - |
| Tsai | Chang-Lan | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Tsai | Shiau-He | - |
| Tsai | Tsung-Yu | Disapprove (a) |
| Tsai | Yi-Hsueh | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Tseng | Fan Shuo | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Tseng | Hsien-Wei | Disapprove (b) |
| Tzavidas | Stavros | Disapprove (b) |
| Ullmann | Rainer | Disapprove |
| Urban | David | - |
| Vadgama | Sunil | Disapprove |
| Vannithamby | Rath | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Venkatachalam | Muthaiah | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Viorel | Dorin | - |
| Vook | Frederick | Disapprove (b) |
| Vrzic | Sophie | - |
| Walker | Kenneth | - |
| Wang | Arthur | - |
| Wang | Chun-Yen | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Wang | Fan | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Wang | Jiacheng | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Wang | Lai-Huei | - |
| Wang | Lei | Disapprove (b) |
| Wang | Li | - |
| Wang | Michael | - |
| Wang | Ping | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Wang | Shu-Shaw | - |
| Wang | Xiaoyi | - |
| Wang | Yanhong | Disapprove (b) |
| Ward | Matthew | - |
| Watanabe | Fujio | Approve, No Comments |
| Watanabe | Yoshikazu | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Wei | Hung-Yu | Disapprove (a) |
| Willey | Dan | - |
| Wu | Ciouping | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Wu | Jia-Hao | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Wu | Qi | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Wu | Shih-Lin | - |
| Wu | Xuyong | Disapprove (b) |
| Xia | Xin | - |
| Xie | Chengjie | - |
| Xu | Changlong | Approve, No Comments |
| Xu | Hongliang | - |
| Xu | Hua | - |
| Xu | Jin | Disapprove (b) |
| Xu | Ling | Disapprove |
| Yaghoobi | Hassan | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Yang | Chang Feng | - |
| Yang | Chih-Cheng | Disapprove (a) |
| Yang | Feng-Ming | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Yang | Hongwei | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Yang | Rongzhen | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Yang | Xiangying | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Yang | Yunsong | Disapprove (b) |
| Yanover | Vladimir | Disapprove (b) |
| Yeh | Choong Il | - |
| Yin | Hua-Chiang | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Yin | Hujun | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Yoo | Hwasun | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Yoshii | Isamu | Disapprove (b) |
| Yu | Hyunkyu | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Yu | Kai | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Yuk | Young Soo | Disapprove (b) |
| Yun | Jungnam | - |
| Zein | Nader | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Zeira | Eldad | Disapprove (b) |
| Zeng | Yunbao | - |
| Zhang | Jie | - |
| Zhang | Jinyun | - |
| Zhang | Kaibin | Disapprove |
| Zhang | Yuantao | - |
| Zhao | Zheng | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Zheng | Haihong | - |
| Zheng | Xufeng | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Zheng | Yan-Xiu | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Zheng | Zhongbin | - |
| Zhou | Hua | Disapprove (a) |
| Zhou | Lei | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Zhu | Chenxi | - |
| Zhu | Jing | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Zhu | Peiying | Disapprove |
| Zhu | Yuan | Approve, Comments (b) |