| Attendees: Held as part of 802.17 WG plenary session, so all attendees of the WG were attendees of the IEEE P802.17 Maintenance Task Group. |
| Maintenance request 0001 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: In 11.2.6.secMac[2].NOT_USED, change "zero" to "all ones". In 11.4.7 change "This ATT supplies two 48-bit secondary MAC addresses" to "This ATT supplies two fields, each of which contains either a 48-bit unicast secondary MAC address, or the NOT_USED (all ones) value". |
| Maintenance request 0002 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Change "The left column specifies the P1-span and P2-span degradations that lead to the protected topology figure in the right column." to "The left column specifies the P1-span and P2-span protection states that lead to the protected topology figure in the right column.". Change the first two column headings in Figure 11-29 to "P1 span state" and "P2 span state". Change "An MS on two distinct spans causes both to be cleared, because the precedence is ambiguous, but an MS on two links of a span still results in an edge." to "Concurrent MS protection states on two distinct spans causes both to be cleared, because the precedence is ambiguous. If one MS is known to be active on one span, an MS request for another span is rejected. Two MS requests on two links of the same span still results in an edge.". |
| Maintenance request 0003 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: In the Reachable() routine description, change "topoEntry[ringlet][index].reachability" to "topoEntry[Other(ringlet)][index].reachability" and change "topoEntry[ringlet][index].myMacAddress" to "topoEntry[Other(ringlet)][index].myMacAddress". |
| Maintenance request 0004 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Change the variable references in 10.2.4 and 10.4.1.2 from "myTopoInfo.unreservedRate[ri]" to "ringInfo.unreservedRate[ri]". |
| Maintenance request 0005 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Remove Row 6. Modify Row 7 condition from "frame.ft == FT_DATA && frame.fcs != Crc32(frame)" to "frame.ft == FT_DATA && !copyBadFcs && frame.fcs != Crc32(frame)". Add a row into the COPY state before Row 17 with a condition of "frame.fcs != Crc32(frame)" and an action of "badRxFcsFrames +=1; Enqueue(Q_RX_F_D_CNT, frame);" and a next state of "START". Remove the row description of Row 6. Modify the row description of Row 7 from "Discard bad-payload data frames." to "Discard bad-payload data frames if the client does not want them.". Add a row description for the new row before Row 17 consisting of the former Row 6's description. |
| Maintenance request 0006 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0007 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0008 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0009 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Add the following lines to the beginning of page 340 (directly before "// Edge reached"). "If ((hops == 1) && (ringlet == ri)) awayState = Max(awayState, tp.spanProtState[ri]); else awayState = Max(awayState, Max(tp.spanProtState[ri], tp.spanProtState[Other(ri)]));". Note: The declation of Max() will be resolved as part MR 23. |
| Maintenance request 0010 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0011 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0012 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0013 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: New status: C Discussion: All but interval time ranges accepted. Thinking about the interval time ranges overnight. |
| Maintenance request 0014 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R Discussion: Concern over whether this is an error or an enhancement. Revisit later. |
| Maintenance request 0015 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: No New status: J Resolution: This is an enhancement request, and is therefore rejected. This can be reconsidered for a future revision of the MIB. |
| Maintenance request 0016 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: C This is superceded by MR 13. |
| Maintenance request 0017 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Change page 487 rprSpanProtectHoldOffTimer range from "(0..500)" to "(0..20)". Change units from "milliseconds" to "10 milliseconds". Add to description "Indicates the protection holdoff timer in 10 ms units." |
| Maintenance request 0018 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0019 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0020 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0021 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0022 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0023 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0024 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0025 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0026 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Change "operational down state" to "operational state". |
| Maintenance request 0027 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R Discussion: Concern over whether this is an error or an enhancement. Revisit later. |
| Maintenance request 0028 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R Discussion: Concern over whether this is an error or an enhancement. Revisit later. |
| Maintenance request 0029 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0030 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Change "transmitTpFrame == FALSE;" to "transmitTpFrame = FALSE;". |
| Maintenance request 0031 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0032 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0033 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0034 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0035 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0036 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0037 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0038 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0039 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R Discussion: Concern over whether this is an error or an enhancement. Revisit later. |
| Maintenance request 0040 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R Discussion: Concern over whether this is an error or an enhancement. Revisit later. |
| Maintenance request 0041 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R Discussion: Concern over whether this is an error or an enhancement. Revisit later. |
| Maintenance request 0042 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R Discussion: Concern over whether this is an error or an enhancement. Revisit later. |
| Maintenance request 0043 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R Discussion: Concern over whether this is an error or an enhancement. Revisit later. |
| Maintenance request 0044 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0045 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: B Resolution: Change the condition of Table 11.13 Row 16 to "-". Change the action of Table 11.13 Row 16 to "protMisconfigDefect = MismatchedProtection();". Change the description of Row 16 to "Update the protection misconfiguration defect.". Remove Table 11.13 Row 17 and the description of Row 17. |
| Maintenance request 0046 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: New status: T Discussion: The current thought is that MR 9 will fix this problem. This needs to be verified. |
| Maintenance request 0047 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: T |
| Maintenance request 0048 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: Yes New status: T Discussion: It is agreed that the definitions do not match the state machines. The request is to modify the state machines to match the definitions. This is not immediately agreeable. This will be thought about some more. |
| Maintenance request 0049 Errata/Technical: Technical Ballot Required: New status: T Discussion: Need to consult with others to determine if this is an "error" or as planned. |
| Maintenance request 0050 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0051 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0052 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R Discussion: Concern over whether this is an error or an enhancement. Revisit later. |
| Maintenance request 0053 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R Noted that the client stats tables are not currently indexed per ringlet in the MIB, although they are in Clause 7. Discussion on whether this is a fix or an enhancement. No resolution at this point. |
| Maintenance request 0054 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |
| Maintenance request 0055 Errata/Technical: Ballot Required: New status: R |