[Home] . [What's New?] . [Active Ballots] . [Minutes] . [Meetings] . [Maintenance] . [Interpretations] . [Public Docs] . [Committee Docs]
[Local Address Study Group] . [802 Architecture Group] . [Data Center Bridging Task Group] [Time-Sensitive Networking Task Group]
[Email] . [Ancient Email] . [802.1 MIBs] . [802.1 OIDs] . [IEEE 802] . [IEEE 802 PARs]
TSN: [802] . [802a] . [802b] . [802.1D] . [802.1D-2004] . [802.1G] . [802.1H-REV] . [802.1Q] . [802.1Q-2014] . [802.1s] . [802.1v] . [802.1w] . [802.1AB-2005] . [802.1AB-2009] . [802.1AC-2012] . [802.1AC-2016] . [802.1ad] . [802.1ag] . [802.1ah] . [802.1aj] . [802.1ak] . [802.1ap] . [802.1aq] . [802.1Qaw] . [802.1AX-2008] . [802.1Qay] . [802.1Qbc] . [802.1Qbe] . [802.1Qbf] . [802.1AXbk] . [802.1Qbp] . [802.1AX-2014] . [802.1AX-Rev] . [802.1Qbz] . [802.1Qca]
[802.1AS] . [802.1AS-Rev] . [802.1Qat] . [802.1Qav] . [802.1BA] . [802.1Qbu] . [802.1Qbv] . [802.1CB] . [802.1Qcc] . [802.1Qch] . [802.1CM] . [802.1Qcn] . [802.1Qcp] . [802.1Qcr]
Security: [802.1X-2001] . [802.1X-2004] . [802.1X-2010] . [802.1AE] . [802.1af] . [802.1AR] . [802.1AEbn] . [802.1AEbw] . [802.1Xbx] . [802.1ARce] . [802.1AEcg] . [802.1Xck] . [802E]
DCB: [802.1Qau] . [802.1Qaz] . [802.1Qbb] . [802.1Qbg] . [802.1Qbh] . [802.3bd] . [802.1BR] . [802.1Qcd] . [802.1Qcj] . [802c] . OmniRAN: [802.1CF]

Interpretation #1
Request
Request for Interpretation of whether or not a loss of link causes a
spanning tree topology change.


Response

The text of IEEE Std 802.1D:1998 does not explicitly couple the
operational state of a MAC to the Disabled Port state; however, the
intent of the standard is that detectable failure of a MAC should
cause the Bridge Port supported by that MAC to enter the Disabled
state, as indicated by the last paragraph of 8.3.5 and the explanation
of the port state transitions of type (2) shown in Figure 8-3. A
transition to the Disabled Port state causes the Bridge to initiate a
topology change notification, unless, for the Port concerned, topology
change detection has been explicitly disabled (8.5.5.10).

Current technical and editorial corrections to this standard, proposed
under project P802.1t, include a macEnabled and a macOperational
parameter in the Internal Sublayer Service definition. The macEnabled
parameter allows administrative control over the availability of a
MAC; the macOperational parameter reflects the operational state of a
MAC, and is set to FALSE if the MAC detects a link failure, or if
macEnabled is FALSE.  The definition of the Disabled Port state is
extended to explicitly state that the Disabled state is entered if
macOperational becomes FALSE.

Pages copyright © Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc. Please read the rules on Confidentiality Statements and Copyright Notices on Communications. Information on Privacy and opting out of cookies is available. If you have any comments on these pages, please send them to me.

Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional Valid CSS!

Last modified by njarvis, at 8:38am on Mon, 15 Jul 2002