Re: [802SEC] 802 workshop Saturday 12 March--updated agenda - comment
Paul,
I see three Q&A options:
1. Allow questions on a slide by slide basis.
2. Allow questions at the end of each presentation
3. Allow questions at the end of the session (as shown in your proposed agenda)
Our ability to control the pace is best with option 3 but the interaction with, and satisfaction of, the attendees is best with option 1.
I propose that we begin with option 1. If there is "in room" evidence that there are too many questions we convert to option 2. I would try to avoid option 3 - the time between a question entering someone's head and getting an answer is just too long and frustrating.
I'd also suggest that during your opening remarks you try to calibrate the topic interest of the attendees. We could adjust time allocations based upon their interests.
Bruce
-----Original Message-----
From: ***** IEEE 802 Executive Committee List ***** [mailto:STDS-802-SEC@ieee.org] On Behalf Of Paul Nikolich
Sent: Tuesday, March 08, 2011 7:02 AM
To: STDS-802-SEC@LISTSERV.IEEE.ORG
Subject: 802 workshop Saturday 12 March--updated agenda
Dear EC members,
Based on the feedback I've received, I've adjusted the presentation times to
reflect the amount of material being covered, as well as who will be doing
the presenting. See below. We will have to reduce the presentation times
in order to finish by 5PM and give 15 minutes for Q&A at the end.
Alternatively, we can allow Q&A during the presentations--but we'll have to
observe strict time limits for each presentation to make sure we cover all
the material in the 4 hours. I'm OK with going overtime as well, if we have
a good audience with a dynamic discussion in process. I'll see if we can
keep the room to 6PM if needed.
We should consider changing the order of presentations a bit when we meet
11AM Saturday (e.g., process, architecture, wireline, wireless; or some
other logical grouping we agree on).
Regards,
--Paul
updated tentative agenda:
1) Welcome--Paul, 5 min
2) IEEE, IEEE-SA Overview--Bob Grow 5 min
3) 802-style standard dev process overview--Jon 5 min
4) SA/802-policy and procedure--Mat 5 min
5) 802 Architecture--JamesG/Tony 5 min
6) 802.1 overview--Tony 30 min
7) 802.3 -- David 30 min
8) 802.11 --Bruce 30 min
--break--15min
9) 802.15 --BobH 30 min
10) 802.16--MatS 30 min
11) 802.17--John 10 min
12) 802.18--Mike 5 min
13) 802.19--Tuncer Baykas 15 min
14) 802.20--Radikrishna 5 min? --missing preso--
15) 802.21--Subir 30 min
16) 802.22--Apurva 20 min
17) 802.23--Geoff 5 min? --missing preso--
18) Q&A
19) Wrap up--Paul
----------
This email is sent from the 802 Executive Committee email reflector. This list is maintained by Listserv.
----------
This email is sent from the 802 Executive Committee email reflector. This list is maintained by Listserv.