* * *
IEEE P802.3ch Multi-Gigabit Automotive Ethernet PHY Task Force
* * *
Comments received on IEEE P802.3ch draft
* * *

Standards Association Ballot Draft D3.2 (2nd. recirculation SA Ballot)

D3.2 final responses (19 March 2020)

D3.2 received comment with response (Received Mandatory Editorial Response comment with APPROVE response)

Standards Association Ballot Draft D3.1 (1st. recirculation SA Ballot)

D3.1 final responses (Excel spreadsheet) (Updated February 26, 2020)

D3.1 final responses (sorted by clause/subclause) (Updated February 26, 2020)

D3.1 proposed responses (Excel spreadsheet) (Updated February 25, 2020)

D3.1 proposed responses (sorted by clause/subclause) (Updated February 25, 2020)

D3.1 proposed responses EZ bucket

D3.1 proposed responses late comments (Updated February 25, 2020)

D3.1 received comments (Excel spreadsheet) V2 (updated February 18, 2020)

D3.1 received comments (sorted by clause/subclause)  (8 comments received)

D3.1 received late comments (sorted by clause/subclause)  (4 comments received)

Standards Association Ballot Draft D3.0 (Initial SA Ballot)

D3.0 final responses (Excel spreadsheet)

PDF of Annex 149-A2

D3.0 final responses (sorted by clause/subclause)

D3.0 final responses (sorted by Comment ID)

D3.0 final responses (sorted by page/line)

D3.0 final responses by topic

D3.0 unsatisfied comment

D3.0 proposed responses (Excel spreadsheet)

D3.0 proposed responses (sorted by clause/subclause)

D3.0 proposed responses (sorted by Comment ID)

D3.0 proposed responses (sorted by page/line)

D3.0 proposed responses by topic

D3.0 proposed responses EZ bucket

D3.0 proposed responses late comments (January 14, 2020)

Proposed response for comment 51 (Shown as a PDF due to complex formatting)

D3.0 received comments (Excel spreadsheet)

D3.0 received comments (sorted by clause/subclause)

D3.0 received comments (sorted by Comment ID)

D3.0 received comments (sorted by page/line)

D3.0 received comments (late - updated January 6, 2020)

103045400003-Figure149A-2_Comment_RevA (Comments i-47 & i-48)

Working Group Ballot Draft D2.2 (2nd recirculation WG Ballot)

D2.2 final responses (Excel spreadsheet)

D2.2 final responses (sorted by Topic)

D2.2 final responses (sorted by clause/subclause)

D2.2 final responses (sorted by Comment ID)

D2.2 final responses (sorted by page/line)

D2.2 proposed responses (Excel spreadsheet)

D2.2 proposed responses (EZ bucket)

D2.2 proposed responses (sorted by Topic)

D2.2 proposed responses (sorted by clause/subclause)

D2.2 proposed responses (sorted by Comment ID)

D2.2 proposed responses (sorted by page/line)

D2.2 received comments (Excel spreadsheet)

D2.2 received comments (sorted by clause/subclause)

D2.2 received comments (sorted by Comment ID)

D2.2 received comments (sorted by page/line)

Unsatisfied required comments from D2.0 (updated 10 October 2019)

Working Group Ballot Draft D2.1 (1st recirculation WG Ballot)

D2.1 unsatisfied required comments - none

D2.1 final comments with approved responses (Excel spreadsheet)

D2.1 final comments with approved responses by comment ID

D2.1 final comments with approved responses by page/line

D2.1 final comments with approved responses by clause/subclause

D2.1 final comments with approved responses by topic

D2.1 received late comment no response 9/11/2019 NAW

D2.1 in progress final responses 9/10/2019 6:45 PM (Excel spreadsheet)

D2.1 updated proposed responses for comments 22, 51, 79, 130, 136, & 169 (Excel spreadsheet) Updated 9/5/2019

D2.1 proposed responses (Excel spreadsheet)

D2.1 proposed responses (sorted by clause/subclause)

D2.1 proposed responses (sorted by Comment ID)

D2.1 proposed responses (sorted by page/line)

D2.1 proposed responses (sorted by topic)

D2.1 EZ bucket proposed responses

D2.1 received comments (Excel spreadsheet)

D2.1 received comments (sorted by clause/subclause)

D2.1 received comments (sorted by Comment ID)

D2.1 received comments (sorted by page/line)

D2.1 received late comments

Working Group Ballot Draft D2.0 (Initial WG Ballot)

D2.0 unsatisfied comments with approved responses by clause/subclause

D2.0 final comments (Excel spreadsheet)

D2.0 final comments with approved responses by comment ID

D2.0 final comments with approved responses by page/line

D2.0 final comments with approved responses by clause/subclause

D2.0 final comments with approved responses by topic

D2.0 closed comments status Wednesday morning July 17, 2019 (Excel spreadsheet)

D2.0 proposed responses and closed comments-updated Wednesday morning July 17, 2019 (Excel spreadsheet)

D2.0 proposed responses and closed comments with homework assignments-updated EOB Tuesday July 16,2019 (Excel spreadsheet)

D2.0 proposed responses and closed comments-updated EOB Monday July 15,2019 (Excel spreadsheet)

D2.0 proposed responses-updated (Excel spreadsheet)

D2.0 comments with proposed responses (sorted by topic)-updated

D2.0 comments with proposed responses (sorted by clause/page/line)-updated

D2.0 comments with proposed response (sorted by clause/subclause)-updated

D2.0 comments with proposed response (sorted by Comment ID)-updated

D2.0 EZ2 bucket proposed responses

D2.0 EZ bucket proposed responses

D2.0 received comments (sorted by clause/subclause)

D2.0 received comments (sorted by Comment ID)

D2.0 received comments (sorted by page/line)

D2.0 received late comments

D2.0 received comments (Excel spreadsheet)

Task Force Draft D1.3 (3rd. Recirculation)
No comments were received on D1.3
Task Force Draft D1.2 (2nd. Recirculation)
	D1.2 final comments with approved responses (Excel spreadsheet)
	D1.2 final comments with approved responses (sorted by Comment ID)
	D1.2 comments with approved responses (sorted by topic)
	D1.2 final comments with approved responses (sorted by page/line)
	D1.2 final comments with approved responses (sorted by clause/subclause)
	D1.2 comments with April 16 progress responses for review (Excel spreadsheet)
	D1.2 proposed responses EZ bucket (sorted by clause/subclause)
	D1.2 comments with proposed responses (sorted by topic)
	D1.2 comments with proposed responses (sorted by clause/page/line)
	D1.2 comments with proposed response (sorted by clause/subclause)
	D1.2 comments with proposed response (sorted by Comment ID)
	D1.2 comment statistics by clause
	D1.2 comments statistic by topic
	D1.2 proposed responses (Excel spreadsheet)
	D1.2 received comments (late)
	D1.2 received comments (sorted by clause/subclause)
	D1.2 received comments (sorted by Comment ID)
	D1.2 received comments (sorted by page/line)
	D1.2 received comments (Excel spreadsheet)

Task Force Draft D1.1 (1st. Recirculation)

D1.1 final comments with approved responses (Excel spreadsheet)

D1.1 final comments with approved responses (sorted by Comment ID)

D1.1 comments with proposed responses (sorted by topic)

D1.1 final comments with approved responses (sorted by page/line)

D1.1 final comments with approved responses (sorted by clause/subclause)

D1.1 final comments with approved responses for review (Excel spreadsheet)

D1.1 proposed responses VERY late comments (sorted by clause/subclause)

D1.1 proposed responses late comments (sorted by clause/subclause)

D1.1 proposed responses Editorial bucket (sorted by clause/subclause)

D1.1 proposed responses EZ bucket (sorted by clause/subclause)

D1.1 comments with proposed responses (sorted by topic)

D1.1 comments with proposed responses (sorted by clause/page/line)

D1.1 comments with proposed response (sorted by clause/subclause)

D1.1 comments with proposed response (sorted by Comment ID)

D1.1 comment statistics by clause

D1.1 comments statistic by topic

D1.1 proposed responses (Excel spreadsheet)

D1.1 received comments (late)

D1.1 received comments (sorted by clause/subclause)

D1.1 received comments (sorted by Comment ID)

D1.1 received comments (sorted by page/line)

D1.1 received comments (Excel spreadsheet)

Task Force Draft D1.0a

D1.0a final comments with approved responses (Excel spreadsheet)

D1.0a, final comments with approved responses (sorted by Comment ID)

D1.0a, final comments with approved responses (sorted by page/line)

D1.0a, final comments with approved responses (sorted by clause/subclause)

D1.0a final comments with approved responses for review (Excel spreadsheet)

D1.0a proposed responses (Excel spreadsheet) (Comment database status 14 January 2019, 6:25 PM PT)

D1.0a proposed responses VERY late comments (sorted by clause/subclause)

D1.0a proposed responses late comments (sorted by clause/subclause)

D1.0a proposed responses Editorial bucket (sorted by clause/subclause)

D1.0a proposed responses EZ bucket (sorted by clause/subclause)

D1.0a, comments with proposed responses (sorted by topic)

D1.0a, comments with proposed responses (sorted by clause/page/line)

D1.0a, comments with proposed response (sorted by clause/subclause)

D1.0a, comments with proposed response (sorted by Comment ID)

D1.0a, comment statistics by clause

D1.0a, comments statistic by topic

D1.0a proposed responses (Excel spreadsheet) (Updated to include late comments)

D1.0a, received comments (sorted by clause/subclause) (Updated to add missing comments)

D1.0a, received comments (sorted by Comment ID) (Updated to add missing comments)

D1.0a, received comments (sorted by page/line) (Updated to add missing comments)

D1.0a received comments (Excel spreadsheet) (Updated to add missing comments)

Task Force Draft D0.6

D0.6, final comments with approved responses (sorted by Comment ID)

D0.6, final comments with approved responses (sorted by page/line))

D0.6, final comments with approved responses (sorted by clause/subclause)

D0.6 final comments with approved responses for review (Excel spreadsheet)

D0.6 proposed responses EZ bucket (sorted by clause/subclause)

D0.6, comments with proposed responses (sorted by topic)

D0.6, comments with proposed responses (sorted by clause/page/line)

D0.6, comments with proposed response (sorted by clause/subclause)

D0.6, comments with proposed response (sorted by Comment ID)

D0.6 proposed responses (Excel spreadsheet)

D0.6, received comments (sorted by clause/subclause)

D0.6, received comments (sorted by Comment ID)

D0.6, received comments (sorted by page/line)

D0.6 received comments (Excel spreadsheet)

Task Force Draft D0.5
	D0.5, final comments with approved responses (Excel spreadsheet)
	D0.5, final comments with approved responses (sorted by topic)
	D0.5, final comments with approved responses (sorted by clause/page/line)
	D0.5, final comments with approved responses (sorted by clause/subclause)
	D0.5, final comments with approved responses (sorted by Comment ID)
	D0.5 proposed responses EZ bucket (sorted by clause/subclause)
	D0.5 late comments
	D0.5, comments with proposed responses (sorted by clause/page/line)
	D0.5, comments with proposed response (sorted by clause/subclause)
	D0.5, comments with proposed response (sorted by Comment ID)
	D0.5 proposed responses (Excel spreadsheet)
	D0.5, received comments (sorted by clause/subclause)
	D0.5, received comments (sorted by Comment ID)
	D0.5, received comments (sorted by page/line)
	D0.5 received comments (Excel spreadsheet)

---

Return to IEEE P802.3ch Task Force Area
Last Update: 19 March 2019

---