Comments on IEEE P802.3cg Drafts

All comments received in an Excel Spreadsheet as of 8/07/2019 (to help Review)

(the following file was received with comments – stewart_0819_01.pdf )

D3.1 First Recirculation SA Ballot comments

Unclosed (unsatisfied and waiting for commenter) comments as of 22-July-2019

Final reports to be posted to myBallot – 7/17/19

(Comments 76, 178, 211 aligned to Revcom guidelines under editorial license)

Unclosed (unsatisfied and waiting for commenter) comments as of 17-July-2019

Comments received with aligned responses sorted by comment ID

Comments received with aligned responses sorted by clause/subclause

Comments received with aligned responses sorted by page/line #

Comments received with aligned responses sorted by topic

Comments received with aligned responses in Excel spreadsheet

(Working report during meeting)

WORKING response comment database – end of day 16 July 2019 – Excel format

(LATE Comments: 7/15/19)

Late comments received with proposed responses sorted by comment ID

(Pre-meeting reports 6/27/19 – Editor’s proposed responses, Editor’s EZ bucket, Editorial bucket)

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by comment ID

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by clause/subclause

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by page/line #

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by topic

All comments received with Topics and Proposed Responses in an Excel Spreadsheet

(only the inclusion of late comments into the database is expected to be approved by motion – the resolution of the comments themselves will be addressed separately, with the other comments)

[AS OF 6/27/19, THERE ARE NO LATE COMMENTS]

SUBSETS TO EXPECTED TO BE APPROVED BY MOTION:

Please review prior to the meeting and email the number of any comment you wish to be excluded from the motion and discussed separately. No explanation required.

Action before Wednesday July 10 is appreciated.

“EZ Bucket” comments with proposed resolutions sorted by Comment ID

“Editorial” comments with proposed resolutions sorted by Comment ID

(Initial reports 6/24/19 – no proposed responses or categories yet

All comments received in an Excel Spreadsheet as of 6/24/2019 (to help Review)

(no files were received with comments)

D3.0 Initial SA Ballot comments

Unclosed (unsatisfied and waiting for commenter) comments as of 27-June-2019

(Final reports posted to myBallot – 5/27/19

– including Editor’s alignment to RevCom guidelines (see: alignment_report for adjustments)

Comments received with aligned responses sorted by comment ID

Comments received with aligned responses sorted by clause/subclause

Comments received with aligned responses sorted by page/line #

Comments received with aligned responses sorted by topic

Unclosed (unsatisfied and waiting for commenter) comments as of 6-June-2019

All comments with Topics and aligned Responses in an Excel Spreadsheet

(Prelim reports from close of CRG meeting – 5/24/19

– before Editor’s final check for RevCom guidelines)

Comments received with prelim responses sorted by comment ID

Comments received with prelim responses sorted by clause/subclause

Comments received with prelim responses sorted by page/line #

Comments received with prelim responses sorted by topic

All comments with Topics and Prelim Responses in an Excel Spreadsheet

(Working reports during CRG meeting – as of End of day 5/23/19)

All Comments resolution status EOD 23 May 2019 by comment ID

Comments remaining to respond EOD 23 May 2019 to with proposed responses sorted by clause/subclause

All comments with Topics and Responses/Proposed Responses as of EOD 23 May 2019 in an Excel Spreadsheet

(Pre-meeting reports 5/10/19 – Editor’s proposed responses, Editor’s EZ bucket, Editorial bucket)

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by comment ID

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by clause/subclause

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by page/line #

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by topic

All comments received with Topics and Proposed Responses in an Excel Spreadsheet

(only the inclusion of late comments into the database is expected to be approved by motion – the resolution of the comments themselves will be addressed separately, with the other comments)

[AS OF 5/10/19, THERE ARE NO LATE COMMENTS]

SUBSETS TO EXPECTED TO BE APPROVED BY MOTION:

Please review prior to the meeting and email the number of any comment you wish to be excluded from the motion and discussed separately. No explanation required.

Action before Sunday May 19 is appreciated.

“EZ Bucket” comments with proposed resolutions sorted by Comment ID

“Editorial” comments with proposed resolutions sorted by Comment ID

(Initial reports 5/4/19 – no proposed responses or categories yet

All comments received in an Excel Spreadsheet as of 5/4/2019 (to help Review)

Files submitted with comments:

Comment_i-45_Baggett_3cg_PLCA_Table_147-6_typo_errors.pdf

Comment_i-188_Beruto_3cg_fig_148_4.png

Comment_i-198_Koczwara_3cg_PLCA_improvement_for_high_node_count.pdf (v1p7)

Comment_i-320_Baggett_3cg_PLCA_timing.pdf

Comment_i-321_Stewart_3cg_clause_104_modifications_v1.pdf

Working Group Ballot:

Unsatisfied comments as of 12-Mar-2019: d2p4, d2p3, d2p2, d2p1, and d2p0

(2 commenters, 69 comments, no unclosed, all unsatisfied)

Separated reports below:

D2.4 Unsatisfied comments by ID as of 12-Mar-2019 (1 commenter, 4 comments)

D2.3 Unsatisfied comments by ID as of 12-Mar-2019 (2 commenters, 16 comments)

D2.2 Unsatisfied comments by ID as of 12-Mar-2019 (2 commenters, 23 comments)

D2.1 Unsatisfied comments by ID as of 12-Mar-2019 (1 comment)

D2.0 Unsatisfied comments by ID as of 12-Mar-2019 (2 commenters, 25 comments)

D2.4 4^th Working Group Recirculation comments

(Resolved comment reports 3/12/19 – resolved during March Plenary)

All comments received with resolutions sorted by comment ID

All comments received with resolutions sorted by page/line #

All comments received with resolutions sorted by clause/subclause

All comments received with resolutions sorted by topic

All d2p4 comments with resolutions in an Excel Spreadsheet (NOTE – this is provided for information only. If there are any discrepancies, please see the PDF reports)

(Pre-meeting reports 3/10/19 – proposed responses, Editor’s Editorial bucket (no EZ bucket))

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by comment ID

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by clause/subclause

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by page/line #

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by topic

All comments received with Topics and Proposed Responses in an Excel Spreadsheet

SUBSETS TO EXPECTED TO BE APPROVED BY MOTION:

Please review prior to the meeting and email the number of any comment you wish to be excluded from the motion and discussed separately. No explanation required.

(no EZ bucket)

“Editorial” comments with proposed resolutions sorted by ID

(Initial reports 3/9/19 – no proposed responses or categories yet)

All comments received with resolutions sorted by comment ID

Unsatisfied comments as of 9-Mar-2019: d2p3, d2p2, d2p1, and d2p0

Separated reports below:

D2.3 Unclosed comments* by ID as of 9-Mar-2019 (2 commenters, 17 comments)

*(1 unsatisfied, 16 unclosed)

D2.2 Unclosed comments by ID as of 9-Mar-2019 (2 commenters, 39 comments)

D2.1 Unsatisfied comments by ID as of 9-Mar-2019 (1 comment)

D2.0 Unclosed comments as of 9-Mar-2019 (2 commenters, 33 comments)

Unsatisfied comments as of 20-Feb-2019: d2p3, d2p2, d2p1, and d2p0

Separated reports below:

D2.3 Unclosed comments* by ID as of 20-Feb-2019 (2 commenters, 26 comments)

*(1 unsatisfied, 25 unclosed)

D2.2 Unclosed comments by ID as of 7-Feb-2019 (2 commenters, 42 comments)

D2.1 Unsatisfied comments by ID as of 7-Feb-2019 (1 comment)

D2.0 Unclosed comments as of 7-Feb-2019 (3 commenters, 39 comments)

D2.3 3rd Working Group Recirculation comments

(Resolved comment reports 2/20/19 – resolved during Feb Interim)

All comments received with resolutions sorted by page/line #

All comments received with resolutions sorted by clause/subclause

All comments received with resolutions sorted by topic

All d2p3 comments with resolutions in an Excel Spreadsheet (NOTE – this is provided for information only. If there are any discrepancies, please see the PDF reports)

(Pre-meeting reports 2/13/19 – proposed responses, Editor’s EZ bucket, Editorial bucket, Late comments)

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by comment ID

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by clause/subclause

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by page/line #

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by topic

All comments received with Topics and Proposed Responses in an Excel Spreadsheet

(only the inclusion of late comments into the database is expected to be approved by motion – the resolution of the comments themselves will be addressed separately, with the other comments)

Late comments with proposed resolutions sorted by clause/subclause

SUBSETS TO EXPECTED TO BE APPROVED BY MOTION:

Please review prior to the meeting and email the number of any comment you wish to be excluded from the motion and discussed separately. No explanation required. Action by Sunday February 17 is appreciated.

“EZ Bucket” comments with proposed resolutions sorted by clause/subclause

“Editorial” comments with proposed resolutions sorted by clause/subclause

(Initial reports 2/10/19 – no proposed responses or categories yet

All comments received in an Excel Spreadsheet (to help Review)

D2.2 2nd Working Group Recirculation:

Unclosed comments as of 7-Feb-2019: d2p2, d2p1, and d2p0

Separated reports below:

D2.2 Unclosed comments* by ID as of 7-Feb-2019 (2 commenters, 42 comments)

D2.1 Unsatisfied comments by ID as of 7-Feb-2019 (1 comment)

D2.0 Unclosed comments* as of 7-Feb-2019 (3 commenters, 39 comments)

Unclosed comments as of 25-Jan-2019: d2p2, d2p1, and d2p0

Separated reports below:

D2.2 Unclosed comments* by ID as of 25-Jan-2019 (2 commenters, 63 comments)

*(1 unsatisfied, 62 unclosed – no response)

D2.1 Unsatisfied comments by ID as of 25-Jan-2019 (1 comment)

D2.0 Unclosed comments* as of 25-Jan-2019 (3 commenters, 47 comments)

*(16 unsatisfied, 31 unclosed – no response)

D2.2 2nd Working Group Recirculation comments

(Resolved comment reports 1/19/19 – resolved during Jan Interim)

All comments received with resolutions sorted by comment ID

All comments received with resolutions sorted by page/line #

All comments received with resolutions sorted by clause/subclause

All comments received with resolutions sorted by topic

All d2p2 comments with resolutions in an Excel Spreadsheet (NOTE – this is provided for information only. If there are any discrepancies, please see the PDF reports)

(Pre-meeting reports 1/4/19 – proposed responses, Editor’s EZ bucket, Editorial bucket, Late comments)

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by comment ID

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by clause/subclause

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by page/line #

Comments received with proposed responses sorted by topic

All comments received with Topics and Proposed Responses in an Excel Spreadsheet

SUBSETS TO EXPECTED TO BE APPROVED BY MOTION:

Please review prior to the meeting and email the number of any comment you wish to be excluded from the motion and discussed separately. No explanation required. Action by Friday January 11 is appreciated.

“EZ Bucket” comments with proposed resolutions sorted by clause/subclause

“Editorial” comments with proposed resolutions sorted by clause/subclause

(only the inclusion of late comments into the database is expected to be approved by motion – the resolution of the comments themselves will be addressed separately, with the other comments)

Late comments with proposed resolutions sorted by clause/subclause

(Initial reports 12/21/18 – no proposed responses or categories yet – CORRECTED – r1 – 1/2/19

Updated (comments received w/o confidentiality disclaimer) – 1/3/19

All comments received in an Excel Spreadsheet (12/21/18 - to help Review)

Unsatisfied comments as of 2-Dec-2018: d2p0 and d2p1

Separated reports below:

D2.1 Unsatisfied comments by clause as of 2-Dec-2018 (2 commenters, 2 comments)

D2.0 Unclosed comments* as of 2-Dec-2018 (3 commenters, 69 comments)

*(18 unsatisfied, 51 unclosed – no response)

D2.1 1st Working Group Recirculation comments

(Resolved comment reports 11/14/18 – resolved during Nov Plenary)

All comments received with resolutions sorted by comment ID

All comments received with resolutions sorted by page/line #

All comments received with resolutions sorted by clause/subclause

All comments received with resolutions sorted by topic

All d2p1 comments with resolutions in an Excel Spreadsheet (NOTE – this is provided for information only. If there are any discrepancies, please see the PDF reports)

(Pre-meeting reports 11/5/18 – proposed responses, Editor’s EZ bucket, Late comments, ‘Very Late’ comments (not in proposed responses))

Comments received by 10/30/18 (excluding “Very Late”) with proposed responses sorted by comment ID

Comments received 10/30/18 (excluding “Very Late”) with proposed responses sorted by clause/subclause

Comments received by 10/30/18 (excluding “Very Late”)with proposed responses sorted by page/line #

Comments received by 10/30/18 (excluding “Very Late”) with proposed responses sorted by topic

All comments received by 11/5/18 with Topics and Proposed Responses (where applicable) in an Excel Spreadsheet

SUBSETS TO EXPECTED TO BE APPROVED BY MOTION:

Please review prior to the meeting and email the number of any comment you wish to be excluded from the motion and discussed separately. No explanation required. Action by Friday September 7 is appreciated.

“EZ Bucket” comments with proposed resolutions sorted by clause/subclause

Late comments with proposed resolutions sorted by clause/subclause

“Editorial” comments with proposed resolutions sorted by clause/subclause

Very Late comments without proposed resolutions sorted by clause/subclause

(Initial reports 10/28/18 – no proposed responses or categories yet

Late comments marked (comment # 478 and higher)